Here’s a case study in the short-sightedness of politicians in establishing sustainable energy options and leaving behind the reliance on the finite, dwindling and increasingly expensive sources of coal and oil.
In 2006, City of Sydney councillor Chris Harris of the NSW Greens held talks with sustainability expert Michael Mobbs and Sydney University’s Professor David Mills to discuss opportunities of solar thermal power for Sydney.
Mills explained how the solar thermal technology used in his prototype project at the Liddell power plant in the Hunter Valley was progressing. He predicted that the results were so impressive that if the project was expanded, then Sydney could be powered by solar thermal power down the grid within three years.
Avenues of major investment in the technology were readily at hand: adequate land was available at either Moree or Bourke in the state’s north-east where more than adequate sun power is available; Moree sat on an electricity hub; and there was spare capacity on the electricity grid so that the solar thermal energy could run down the line to Sydney.
The Greens released a plan and produced a brochure on the proposal before the state election in March 2007.
What happened? The Iemma Government won the state election, ignored the technology on offer and Professor Mills received no encouragement from Labor ministers. So he pulled up stakes and went to California where he built the world’s largest solar thermal power station with the blessing of Republican Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger. Australian technology was lost.
Now let’s cut to 2008. Iemma sends his Environment and Climate Change Minister Verity Firth on a taxpayer funded junket to Las Vegas to view and learn about Mills’ solar thermal technology, even though she could have seen it in her own backyard at Liddell.
As Harris lamented: “All Ms Firth had to do was take an 80-minute drive where she could have inspected the demonstration which is producing steam to drive turbines using free energy from the sun.”
Back from Las Vegas, Ms Firth is trilling about the solar thermal technology and trying to hide the inconvenient truth that NSW let its technology go offshore, jobs were given away and an opportunity to be a world leader in this field has gone.
Meanwhile, the environment and climate change minister is showing Cabinet solidarity by supporting the advanced plans to open more coal and gas-fired power stations and maintain the myth of “clean coal”.
In today’s Business Spectator, finance writer Robert Gottliebsen delivers a monumental bucketing of the economic mismanagement of NSW (“NSW is the laggard”) saying: “The power farce in NSW makes it time to face a concealed truth about Australia — our biggest problem is NSW.”
With an insouciance for which he is famous, Gottliebsen added: “I also spoke to a number of Queensland CEOs who found doing business straight forward in all eastern states except NSW which they said was a simply ‘a joke’. These Queenslanders either came from NSW or had spent time living there. Since then I have spoken to a wider range of Australian executives who all complained about the difficulty of doing business in the NSW culture.”
That “culture” is more widely known as the NSW the right-wing machine of the NSW Labor Party.
while solar thermal has potential, it does not operate at night.
another technology languishing due to government indifference is planned for Wentworth, on the north side of the Murray near Mildura.
tallest structure in the world
24/7 power generation
200MW output
completely sustainable!
physics textbooks first listed this project as world leading 6 years ago…
it needed $70million to get it going
compare this with wind farms..and other solar thermals
they do not compare
so why?
maybe something to do with mission energy has the patent onthe technology
the market rules…again.
btw the hydrogen economy conference held three years ago postulated thehydrogen economy would ‘kick in’ once petrol hit $4 a litre
so lets raise the price and get on with it!
then we need a low cost source of electricity to make(release) the hydrogen
pity the coal fired generators…all that coal and electricity that no-one will want
seems that is the reason for little/no development of alternatives
only time will tell
the planet will live on…maybe without the humans
That Robert Gottliebsen article from ‘Business Spectator’ was about the worst thing I’ve ever read. Superficial set of arguments that seemed to point to one conclusion only — the need for a ‘WorkChoices’ style IR system in NSW. Telling bizoids what they want to hear, no doubt. It has nothing to do with mistakes in implementing solar research in NSW by Labor. I’m more concerned with Labor’s lack of interest in affordable housing solutions in Sydney, which is also harmful to the economy, and the massive conflicts of interest and potential for corruption between the Minister for Planning and developers, various politicians and Macquarie Bank, and so on.
solar thermal actually operates at night well enough. Fluids are heated during the day and then used to generate steam while the sun is off watch.
It continues a well worn practice of behaviour by the Labor state government. Pacific Solar which was part of the state owned electricity generator Pacific Power , and a leader in PV technology, was sold to foreigners rather than nutured by the government and when Eraring Energy (NSW state owned) tried to build more wind farms in JV with a Spansih outfit NSW treasury made them can the deal well into the planning process. But they are great at having slogans, state plans and advertising campaigns, remember ‘Its a living thing’. What have we done to deserve a mob like this, not to mention the looney/dopey alternative. Could ‘Get Up’ or similiar, please choose a party (toss a coin), organise membership of that party and take it over…. saves on building a new brand and, as Mark Latham so eloquently pointed out in his book : take out the union membership and you are left with only a few thousand actual members of the party. Its time for action in NSW!
PS Maybe the memory of the Harry Messell / Neville Wran solar deal at White Cliffs in NSW’s far west 30 years ago , which was well intentioned but a flop, cruelled it for everyone else, however its not an excuse
Thought you might find this one amusing
Bruce