The contrast, as Kevin Rudd invariably says, was stark. Joe Hockey sat slumped on the seat nearby, gazing up at the Reps chamber ceiling, while Malcolm Turnbull explained why he would be voting for the Government’s CPRS bills.
The body language, surely, was deceiving. Turnbull might have appeared forthright, aggressive even, as he expertly articulated the case for the CPRS far, far better than anyone from the Government ever had – particularly when, in three short sentences about how each recent decade had been hotter than the previous one, he demolished the myth of global cooling promoted by the likes of Tony Abbott.
But Turnbull was alone, reading — if the Press Gallery commentary is correct — the last rites over a political career wrecked on a point of principle, offering only a glimpse of what might have been had he ever mastered his many faults and coupled his undoubted brilliance with a more consultative and reflective style.
But Hockey remains Shadow Treasurer, a key part of the Coalition economics team, under a leader polling better than Turnbull ever did, perhaps a mere 2-3% away from achieving his career goal of Treasurer.
So, Joe, why the long face?
It might possibly be that Hockey was envious that he could never give a speech as good as that, for Turnbull’s speech was, instantly, a classic of Australian politics. So what if it was delivered to a near-empty chamber? Its content was scintillating.
Australian politicians don’t do soaring rhetoric or great oratory and there was none of that in Turnbull’s speech, but there was an intellectual rigour and cold, hard refusal to countenance bullshit that is sadly lacking in modern politics (and, in truth, much of Turnbull’s own period as leader).
No politician, from any party, has ever nailed the case for action on climate change so succinctly, and no politician — and certainly not Kevin Rudd — has ever come close to explaining so clearly why a market-based mechanism is preferable. And in his comprehensive demolition of the Abbott plan — all delivered without mentioning Abbott or the details of the plan, or anything that could be construed as personal criticism — Turnbull has not merely provided the Government with perfect soundbites, but with perfect talking points for its own use.
In fact, it did Hockey great credit that he showed up for the speech when it might have been easier to stay away and try to ignore what was happening. Only he, Russell Broadbent and Petro Georgiou were there for all of it. But Hockey has been in a funk since the leadership spill and what was commonly agreed to be his poor handling of it.
True, he has been keeping up his Parliamentary workrate in Question Time – bellowing incredulously at every utterance from Wayne Swan, laughing operatically at Kevin Rudd, shaking his head in outrage at Harry Jenkins’s bizarre rulings. And there’s recently been a new addition to Hockey’s family, meaning he could be forgiven for paying more attention to the domestic front than usual. But Barnaby Joyce has had a far higher profile on economic issues – disastrously, from the Coalition point of view.
Have a look at the Liberal website where shadow ministers dutifully stick up press releases and transcripts – Hockey is nearly absent. He dutifully followed Abbott round a Canberra supermarket last week, holding watermelons forlornly, as if unable to quite believe that “retail politics” literally meant “retail politics.” Especially as part of a scare campaign on a policy he had strongly supported until December:
[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-zh6Fk2Myc[/youtube]
And sure, it doesn’t help that he found time to play dress-ups on television in the weekend, though if a politician can’t mock himself and show a lighter side occasionally, it’s a pretty sad world we condemn our elected representatives to:
[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSkVMbC2diY[/youtube]
But with Abbott by his own admission uninterested in economics, that leaves Hockey as the economic leader of the Opposition, and he hasn’t been doing much leading. With the Government homing in on the Abbott risk factor, economic credibility will become more and more important. You can’t win a scare campaign if your opponents can show you’re as scary as you say they are.
Hockey can’t sit back and let Joyce wreck what little remaining credibility the Coalition has.
He has to get in the ring and start punching. He might envy Turnbull, who can sit on the backbench and do whatever he pleases, but he has thrown in his lot with Abbott and now has to live with the consequences. At least Abbott won’t die wondering. It’s time his Shadow Treasurer adopted the same approach.
Maybe Joe’s ruminating about his political options – he isn’t a One Nation – Shooters’ Party (LNP) type. Perhaps it isn’t Malcolm’s political obituary that is the issue, rather Joe’s. He made a Twitter comment last week indicating how much he misses his family. And he’s a decent man.
Joe’s heart just isn’t in it anymore. You can tell by the body language.
What he should have done, as did Turnbull, was put his principles before his ambition, and go to the backbench with Turnbull and Michael Keenan, who seems also to have not accepted Abbott’s offer to sup from the poisoned chalice he was offering. Then they could have formed a more substantial rump of principled, small ‘l’ Liberals just biding their time and waiting for Barnaby Joyce and Tony Abbott and crew to inevitably implode.
I have no doubt that Joyce would have jumped at the chance to become Shadow Treasurer, and were it not for the fact that that person needs to be in the Lower House, he probably would’ve been offered the job by the Mad Monk.
So, no doubt, under the threat of dire pre-selection consequences, which seems to have been enough to silence all the other, ‘once-were-principled’ Coalition MPs from crossing the floor with Malcolm, Hockey has half-heartedly gone along with Abbott.
Good article Bernard, I got a similar feeling watching Joe there, chin resting on his hands. For some reason I feel sorry for Joe.
Love the ‘Want to meet sexy people’ ad on the video in the email. You do everything on purpose, clearly.
After being passed over as leader it was clear Joe’s best political years were behind him.
By throwing his weight (and future) behind the Member for Goldman Sachs it was always going to end in tears.
The final nail was yesterday’s moral supporting of Turnbull alongside feculant Liberal stain Petro Georgiou. The writing was on the wall for all to see.
Rather than letting a bitter, power drunk liberal stooge drag Hockey down to his level he should spend more time with his family.
He is a decent man…and they deserve it.
“Turnbull’s assistance” – with his public persona, and reasoned but unpopular views on climate and what needs doing to address the problem – “I’m all out of life-savers would a brick do?”