If there’s anything the demolition of Kevin Rudd should tell us, it is that media image is close to everything in politics.
As we consider the many factors in his demise, we should not discount the role his demeanour on the public stage played. What began as forgivable mannerisms became hateable traits as they became associated with his known personality flaws.
Yesterday, lips quivering, as he failed to hold back emotion, Rudd was human and likeable. It was a moment later, when he told himself off for “blubbering”, that I remembered why I wasn’t devastated he was leaving. That smile of his just seems so sickly or nerdy or fake or, I dunno, something just weird. There it was again when he played with the idea of still being PM while not being the party leader. Sickly smile, followed by a typically awkward quip. “Anything could happen here folks.”
Then came a reference to the “good burghers of Griffith,” which is of course exactly how the Labor voters in his Queensland electorate describe themselves every day.
Oh and that dorky wave of his. It’s really hard to copy. Try it. You have to hold your forearm still while swivelling your hand on its axis at 45 degrees from your waist. It is so unnatural.
I don’t think the ETS was the deciding factor in the polls. I think Rudd’s demise came about more gradually, as the electorate learnt more about his driven character and his cruelty to people on airplanes as well as his policy failings.
Suddenly all those strange affectations took on a new meaning. He was the “fair suck on the sauce bottle” and “in due season” Kevin Rudd, nothing like the knockabout Bob Hawke. Too much like that other round headed little man in glasses, John Howard.
Image is everything. I reckon John Howard lost the 2007 election the day he showed the world he couldn’t bowl a cricket ball. That was the moment Australians stopped listening to him. He simply became a joke.
I’m ashamed to be saying this. I know it is the equivalent of judging people by their hairstyle. I know that the achievements of the Rudd Government — and there are many — deserve more profound analysis than this. But the point is that when honeymoons end and we get to see what really makes our leaders tick, their media presence becomes all powerful.
The long lost Mark Latham alluded to some of this on Sky News this morning. He emerged from his obscurity to gloat in that amusingly vindictive way of his.
Amongst the rant about factions and the evils of various ALP insiders were some revealing snippets about the “transit lounge” nature of political party leadership and the role the media plays.
He pointed out that because Rudd had no factional base, his popularity, and therefore his media image, was everything. When that eroded his “contract with Labor” was over.
Latham told an anecdote about someone he’d met who actually liked Rudd. Latham said he’d told this person “the only reason why you like him is because you haven’t met him.” Ouch!
But increasingly we in the electorate have been meeting Rudd. And we’ve come to like less and less.
Latham also joked about the media’s fascination with Gillard. He said “the media wants some fresh blood that you can suck on later.” It was an astute observation because already there are signs of the characteristics that will eventually undermine her as PM.
Last night on The 7.30 Report there were moments of her brilliance, matching the masterful performance of her acceptance speech. She was candid as she joked with Kerry O’Brien about it being a great day for red heads. She actually answered the odd question, although in too many cases she took way too long to do so.
But for too long she just droned, It was tiresome and mechanistic. She used the terrible phrase “the former Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd” four times, each one sounding more imperious than the last. It seemed for ever before she was able to call him plain old “Kevin.”
For a moment I thought she might take on the same affected manner Bill Hayden adopted after he became Governor General. But mercifully as the interview wore on, she relaxed into it and the humanness returned.
So I guess it’s inevitable that her propensity to avoid questions and to talk like a robot will catch up with her just like Rudd’s general nerdiness caught up with him.
Andrew
Are you just another male journalist who tries to put down women whenever they do more than cook and clean house ? Should they really speak nicely answering everyone’s impertinent questions?
Grow up.
Julia is a excellent politician with the tough skills needed for the job.
Andrew I have every faith in Julia leaving you and other jurnos of similar ilk, in her dust.
Yes, Andrew, you should be ashamed. What a puerile piece, but am sure you’re not alone, so perhaps it needed to be written, even if it’s unpleasant and shallow.
I didn’t have the same reaction as you to the apparent flaws of Kevin Rudd. I found him quite likeable, and I know I’m not alone, based on the discussions I’ve had over the last day or so with friends – including many female friends.
I liked the wave, and the joke about what could happen in his remaining 15 min as PM. I found the farewell speech touching, even if he did go on a bit in the “I’m proud of” section.
Notwithstanding his apparent faults, character or otherwise, maybe this is a triumph of all the bogans and hoods who hang around behind the shelter shed, smoking and deciding which nerd to pick on next. They’re OK at nightclub security, but I wouldn’t want them running the economy.
Proud to be a nerd.
Jenny Morris, thankyou for every point you made. I am in full agreement.
But Andrew, we know that the media industry has gobbled up all the flawless human specimens. Like yourself.
That leaves the rest of us to just make the best of our poor , ordinary personae, failings flaws and all. Though to be fair,we don’t all have an overpaid and underperforming group like the media eagerly waiting to pounce on any manifestation of “character flaws”
Show a bit of imagination and try to remember there are those who are not universally loved, respected and adored like your self and we just have to make it as best we can.
Try to grow up, there’s a good boy.
Thankyou Barbara and Jenny I love what you have both written.
Andrew, I find it disturbing when someone denigrates and laugh at others when they show real emotion . Its like watching a thug kick a person when he is already unconscious .
I know he is a big boy , he is a politician .
BUT , So what
I think it shows more about who you are and the “I am so funny and people laugh when I act like a bully and put others down .
Cmon Andrew your better than that .
This style has been thrashed to death . to be honest I find it boring.