Keane’s Talking Points: worst climate change policy eva
There’s every chance the Government will find a way to have an even worse climate change policy than the Liberals, a truly impressive feat.
article-article-body
- The Coalition’s campaign unit is finally up and running but still no match for the Labor machine. Transcripts are taking far longer to hit inboxes — there are some Liberal campaign transcripts still outstanding from yesterday afternoon, for example. The suspicion remains that the Liberals are under-resourced and out-gunned.
- It’s only the first week but the Coalition’s stand-out performer is (I know this will shock you) Andrew Robb. He has been ubiquitous and on-point right from the kick-off. Yesterday he adroitly handled Labor claims that the education rebate had not been properly costed — “Hawker Britton 101” was a nice line. Joe Hockey, apart from his stoush with Kerry O’Brien, has been keeping a lower profile. In the good old days of Keating and Costello, treasurers and their opposite numbers were front-and-centre in campaigns. The Liberals are saying the shadow treasurer has been used in campaigning below the national media radar. That used to be called being kept out of sight. Will voters eventually notice that the shadow finance spokesman is doing all the economic work instead of the shadow treasurer?
- The media obsess about Kevin Rudd and then use their obsessing about it as evidence that Rudd is “distracting” from the Labor campaign. Better yet, they do it on a day when neither leader campaigns. Classic media-is-always-right reporting. Labor can partly blame itself for deliberately pursuing a strategy of making the campaign as dull as possible in the hope it can sit on its lead til 21 August.
- It wouldn’t be a Crikey election without serial candidate Stephen Mayne throwing his hat in the ring. Mayne, who broke Australia’s longest election drought since the Communist Party in 2008 when he was elected to Manningham Council, will stand for the Senate in Victoria on a no-pokies and (big thumbs up) pro-immigration platform.
- The first key moment of the campaign for Labor will be voter reaction to the climate change policy Labor will unveil later today. A number of reports in both News Limited and Fairfax papers indicate the path to a carbon price will involve a “citizens’ assembly” to consider the issue. Labor’s cynical hardheads better hope voters don’t see this for what it is — the substitution of “consensus” and convenient delay for leadership. The Daily Telegraph has already — rightly — given it a serve. There’s every chance the Government will find a way to have an even worse climate change policy than the Liberals, a truly impressive feat.
- The other component of the Labor announcement, for which there is no detail yet available, is its spending on energy efficiency and renewables. There is $650 million available for such measures — the funding left over, in accrual accounting terms, from the shelving of the CPRS, which despite being a “great big new tax”, was a giant, pollution-supporting hit to the Budget in its early stages. This enables some big ticket announcements that will give the impression of climate action — but nothing more than that. Will Labor roll them out all at once or dribble them out for maximum impact, in order to create the impression they’re actually doing something?
About the Author
Bernard Keane
Politics Editor @BernardKeane
Bernard Keane is Crikey's political editor. Before that he was Crikey's Canberra press gallery correspondent, covering politics, national security and economics.
I’ve always been a fan of Stephen Mayne, good luck to him in his run for the Senate. If he wins a seat he’ll be an endless and interesting source for news grabs for the next few years so the meedya should get behind him if only for self-interest.
That’s certainly what I thought when I first heard about it on the radio this morning.
EPIC FAIL.
Why bother having elected representatives at all, if they’re just going to throw every difficult issue out to a ‘citizens assembly’. May as well just do all our governing by direct plebiscite and be done with it.
Alas Gillard has learned nought from the Rudd debacle on climate change…more talk, more committees, more delay, no guts Julia no guts. A huge majority of the country want action, now, thats action in doing, getting on with it, govern, show leadership…..don’t take the electorate for granted PM. The race is not won until the first runner hits the tape. The public have spoken loudly and clearly on this one, you dont need anymore talkfests, just definitive action. Stop treating us like mugs.
Julia, assemble a panel of scientists, engineers, economists, ecologists, whatever it takes to bring the skills to the table.
Include the specialist departments, pragmatists and boffins. Do what it takes.
But, please, don’t listen to a bunch of “citizens” in the hope that somehow the best and brightest proposals will shine through or that some mysterious consensus will materialise out of nowhere. To do so would be to wimp out.
Take this by the hands as though it was a chunk of your annual budget (which, inevitably, it will be) and drive the agreement that is needed. This also will result in consensus of a kind – the winners will get on with the job and the losers will get over it.
But, for goodness’ sake, please do more than just talk about the climate change issue, and don’t wait till 2012 as I heard you say this morning. What’s wrong with about a week after the election, once your cabinet has been sworn in?
Abbott is about to make a major policy announcement on border control, including as soon as he becomes PM contacting the Nauru PM and taking him up on his offer to use the phosphate heap as a storage unit for asylum seekers (ex ABC NEWS 10am). I await with interest his confirmation of “I will tow the boats back out to sea”.