Well I promised the Crikey editor that today I would not write about Greece and Italy. That decision has been rescinded, by Greece and Italy. For the first time since the European debt crisis began last year, the prospect of a break-up of the euro became a very real and present possibility today. The main cause was the sudden spike in the Italian new bond rate, to 7.5%, as m’colleague Jo McKenna notes, but across the sea, Greece outdid its Mediterranean cousin in bringing da chaos.
Last night, in Athens, there was still no new prime minister or cabinet, despite talks and negotiations going all day. Indeed, there is now no clear front runner for the job. Previous candidate Lucas Papademos, former ECB wonk, has faded from the running, and all talk is now of Filippos Petsalnikos, currently the parliamentary speaker, and a Pasok member. New Democracy leader Antonis Samaras was quoted as saying that he had “no problem” with Petsalnikos as leader, or anyone else George Papandreou could come up with.
The issue was deferred to a meeting at 6pm, Athens time, with the expectation that it would end with the naming of a PM and cabinet. However, leader of the New Orthodoxy party, Giorgos Karatzaferis, left the meeting an hour after it began, accusing Papandreou and Samaras of “playing politics” — the horror! The meeting broke up, with no resolution and the gob-smacking announcement that it would reconvene at 10am tomorrow (about 7pm today Australian time). Since the meeting was preceded by a lachrymose farewell speech by Papandreou, saying that he was leaving to show that Greeks can “all work together”, the sense of absurdity was complete.
The demise of Papademos as a likely candidate was said to be a response to the demands he was making of both parties — chiefly, a longer period of “caretaker” government than the three months set down, and a sideways move for Evangelos Venizelos, the finance minister, deputy PM and de facto leader of Greece. Venizelos is reputed to have vetoed Papademos, but other Pasok MPs are said to be objecting to the selection of Petsalnikos as PM.
A half-dozen other names had been suggested throughout the day, prompting one blogger to note that the news agencies were being used by the numerous factions of the major parties to run their own agendas, a measure of the degree to which a process originally intended to be a response to crisis, has become bogged down in politics as usual. Indeed, the crisis now has a decidedly vertiginous aspect — since Papandreou has now officially resigned, and Greece tonight may or may not have a prime minister.
Italy remains the linchpin, the only major economy with a 7% interest rate danger bailout threshold, due to its high borrowings. But the concern now, at the higher end, is “contagion”, with the bond rates for Spain and France creeping up, north of 4%. No one supposes that they will be in a default zone, but the problem is that the situation will tie up all of southern Europe, Ireland and France — a pretty major chunk of Europe — in a debt trap, pitching the continent into a decade of stagnation.
The exception is, of course, Germany, whose borrowing costs are falling, and the gap between northern and southern Europe widening. That in itself is damages the euro further, since one monetary policy must now cover radically different demands. Germany’s continued refusal to allow for direct intervention by the ECB, to guarantee the supply of money is a mild version of the tension that might later result.
That’s at the big end. At the narrow end, it is surely the capacity of national politics, a la Greece, to drift away from any sense of present emergency, and back into party politics, that would add to the sense that, impossible as it may seem, there may come a point where the euro is simply irrecoverable. As Paul Krugman has noted:
“I still find it hard to believe that the euro will fail; but it seems equally hard to believe that Europe will do what’s needed to avoid that failure. Irresistible force, meet immovable object — and watch the explosion.”
I’ve been a Euro “skeptic” from the start, joint passports is one thing, creating a central bank, joint governance, currency etc is just wrong.
Enjoying watching countries struggle with this ridiculous situation.
It is fascinating to watch this grand experiment teeter on the brink of collapse, all because of the lack of political and cultural will to unite together in aid of a common cause.
Before the common currency and finance, it was easy for a country to make themselves more competitive in economic terms, as this happened through natural adjustments in currency and trade. If Greece were able to devalue their local currency (and somehow restrict labour and capital disappearing across the border) they could restructure their economy to be more competitive in producing cheaper goods and services for their more prosperous neighbours.
This is how it happens in Australia versus the rest of the world. In the past we have seen our currency at a low value compared to today, which meant our goods and services were cheaper than they are now. As long as our economy was able to restructure to deliver the goods and services appropriate for demand, in the long term we would do alright as a nation.
Now that Greek labour and capital has to compete with German, British, French and a whole host of other labour and capital using the same currency, it is much harder to devalue the local cost of both in that country and still prevent them disappearing to neighbouring countries where conditions are more favourable.
Try to imagine standing on a balcony with a megaphone announcing to the population at large that they all taking a 20% pay cut. The psychology of that process is far different to an understated announcement that “the drachma has fallen to new low levels in trading today” – at least for the average worker.
No, there are only two long-term solutions to the problems Greece is facing, and they are structural within the EU. Either dissolve the currency union and allow for the local currency of member states to fluctuate around according to demand, or make steps to restructure the EU to include central financial redistribution according to the local economic needs of a member state, much like what happens in Washington towards the US member states, or like happens in Canberra in the collection and distribution of taxation to Commonwealth states.
Mutual taxation and distribution across the breadth of the single currency, or dissolve the currency.
If the Eurozone implodes in the next few weeks or months, which is looking increasingly more likely, and the full implications of this implosion are felt in massive decline in living standards in the “PIIGS” there will be a lot of handwringing about the inability of politicians, particularly of the Greek and Italian variety to face up to reality while they still had time to take immediate steps to begin to rectify the problem. Without trust in these governments there is no hope.
The current austerity measures that are being proposed for Greece and Italy at the moment will pale to insignificance against the austerity measures required if the “PIIGS” are forced to withdraw from the Eurozone and they have to fend for themselves in terms of financing imports from whatever exports that they can generate with their massively devalued currencies.
Furthermore the massive default realisation will ripple through the whole world banking sector and we will all have cause to curse the recalcitrant politicians who like the parable of the first class Titanic passengers still had ice served in their gin and tonics while third-class passengers trapped below decks were drowning.
It is almost inconceivable that Greek politicians are currently squabbling over who will be the leader when within a month the country will be bankrupt.
However it should be noted that any self-professed”Euro- sceptics” gloating over this tragic failure have outed themselves as joining the ranks of voyeurs who derive pleasure of watching others in pain. Millions will suffer as a consequence of this failure and it should not give pleasure to anybody other than self-obsessed psychopaths.
This is the best thing that could ever happen, Once we get rid of this thing called “corporate globalism” sorry I meant “free trade” in which Mark Vaile of the Nationals was sent as the emissary to the “financial old boys club” we can then stop faceless financial cartels from around the globe turning Australia into a toxic waste dump!!
The way the world has been subverted resembles something more akin to a “Ponzie Scheme”
Once countries revert to their sovereign constitutionality like in the 70s & early 80s we, should then cast of this thing called a reserve bank which is a 3rd party for controlling Australias & other countries wealth. We reserve the right to print our own money without paying some extortion racket interest for using our own cash.
Mind you as soon as JFK signalled this they shot him!!!
Where’s Guiseppe Verdi when you need him to write a new opera? This has all the necessary material for one.