In retrospect, the decision by the Turnbull government to issue a normal Mid Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook rather than use the opportunity of a political reset and a new Treasurer to undertake a mini-budget looks increasingly flawed.
Tomorrow’s MYEFO will show a significant revenue write-down from lower iron ore prices, lower wages growth and lower economic growth projections. Even putting aside Scott Morrison’s weird fiscal denialism in his repeated assertions that Australia “doesn’t have a revenue problem”, there is also the challenge of spending. Morrison has made much of the need to get spending from 26.2% of GDP, the level it reached under Tony Abbott and Joe Hockey, back to the budget forecast for this year of 25.9%.
Hockey took a deliberate decision to continue to pump tens of billions of deficit spending into the economy in the 2014-15 and 2015-16 budgets, and was correct to do so given the tepid economy and unemployment above 6%. But 25.3% of GDP — where spending will still be at in 2018-19 — is too high given an improving economy.
Morrison should be aiming for something closer to the 24.1% of GDP Wayne Swan managed in 2012-13. Regardless of how the tax reform debate plays out and whether Morrison ever snaps out of his “there’s no revenue problem” delusion, the path to surplus lies in a more rapid reduction in spending than the current lazy plan put forward by the government. And the first step on that path should have been tomorrow’s MYEFO.
The treasurer’s policies should be based on information from reliable sources, not ideology.
The story put about by the MSM that the Coalition are ‘better economic managers’, and now believed by far too many voters, is total cr*p!
By any reading of economic history over the last 30 years, Labor have been the best governments at running the economy and the country.
There is no reason to doubt they will continue to be superior to the coalition in this regard. The policies already released by the Opposition show that.
No wonder Ltd News (in particular) have set out to destroy Shorten and Labor….they deliver for the country and the people…not just the top 1%!
LOOK AT EACH PARTY’S POLICIES, NOT ONLY THE LEADERS!!
Operation Sovereign Hoarders…Work Save Invest..Maybe he will stop commenting on treasury matters..
The LNP adults in charge have delivered two dud treasurers in a row, and have almost doubled the deficit in their two years of government. The grand poobah of learners has been rewarded with a diplomatic post as a reward for fiscal mismanagement.
Have a good laugh Wayne Swan, you weren’t such a bad treasurer after all.