“What a mess.”
— J Mascis, Freak Scene
Far from being a restoration of the kind of sensible, just-get-on-with-it leadership the nation has been craving for so long, the new Parliament, and the Turnbull government that notionally presides over it, is beginning to look like a combination of the worst of Australian politics since 2010. And we’re still the best part of a month from Parliament actually sitting.
The week began with the Rudd non-appointment still reverberating around Canberra. Just when that was starting to quieten down, Rudd gave a 75-minute interview to Paul Kelly — it’s hard to imagine whom to feel more sorry for in that Clash of The Tedious — to amplify it again, showing that same deft capacity to garner attention to himself that he deployed so often against Julia Gillard. (And, by the way, didn’t you love the way Rudd portrayed himself and Turnbull as best chums, pals who hung out together at Point Piper and at Kevin’s New York pad, making Turnbull’s refusal to nominate him all the more treacherous?)
Turnbull and his Treasurer, meanwhile, were struggling to deal with a problem that, back in the day, also vexed Rudd, Julia Gillard and their Treasurer, Wayne Swan. When banks declined to pass on interest rate cuts under Swan, the Coalition liked to howl with outrage and mock him as ineffectual. Now, with the big banks passing on half or less of Tuesday’s cut, Morrison tried to have two bob each way on the issue, before Turnbull — with better, or at least less worse political antennae than his Treasurer — waded in to give the banks yet another tongue-lashing.
[Yes the banks are bastards — but …]
Yesterday Turnbull and Morrison conjured an annual appearance for the big four before the House of Reps economic committee, as another instalment in their exhausting campaign to keep the banks out of a royal commission. Helpfully, on that front, Labor began talking this week about peeling off a Nationals MP or two to secure support a House of Reps motion for a royal commission — the kind of thing that is now a serious threat given Turnbull’s slender majority.
If those replays of the Rudd-Gillard years weren’t enough, we’ve now got a wholly new Senate crossbench that suggests the one Turnbull called a double dissolution to dispose of might not have been so bad after all. It’s like a megamix of the 2014-16 crossbench — Lambie, Day and Leyonhjelm are all back, but now they’ve been supplemented by two companions for Nick Xenophon and, of course, not one, not two, not three, but four One Nation senators. Meanwhile, the Coalition and the Greens, who collaborated on the Senate voting changes that were supposed to end the days of micro-party mayhem on the crossbench, together lost four spots.
[The corporate culture wars are wider than banking]
Remember all those plaudits for Turnbull boldly seizing the agenda back in March and declaring he was going to go for a double dissolution election if he didn’t get his way on the ABCC bill? It’s hard to recall a political ploy that has blown up as badly as that in recent times. Turnbull’s government hangs by a thread in the House of Representatives and he has ushered into the Senate a deeply toxic and malicious clutch of bigots and crazies.
Their numbers include an anti-Semitic conspiracy theorist who sees the repeal of section 18c of the Racial Discrimination Act as necessary to enable a discussion about the malign influence of “international bankers” — AKA “the Jews”. These people now have a legitimate platform for their hate — towards Muslims, towards Jews, towards Asians, towards indigenous people, towards women who want divorces, towards climate scientists.
What a mess. And what if 2010-15 ends up looking like we didn’t know how good we had it compared to the disaster we’ve now inflicted on ourselves.
Re the DD “Fools rush in where Angels fear to tread”…..Ignorant or inexperienced individuals get involved in situations that wiser persons would avoid.
That kinda sums up Talcum Fluffypants and his band of Incompetent Mistake Makers
” a deeply toxic and malicious clutch of bigots and crazies.”
They may well be but they are elected representatives and need to be approached with respect. The LNP is particularly skilled in this – or at least they hope to be.
The LNP are ‘skilled’ at NOTHING!
You gotta be joking, yes??!!
I suspect he is joking. As for approaching the crossbench with respect, I recommend in the case of the 4th One Nation chappie (Senator :_+” I think it is) that they approach from behind and accompanied by a team of fully qualified and equipped personel in white coats.
They are certainly elected representatives but what, I wonder does it suggest about their electors? It was Paul Keating I think who reminded us that the people always get it right, but while I’m happy to agree with the Great Man on most things socio-political, on this matter, and more particularly, on this occasion, the nation seems to have got it badly wrong; and could it be that we’re travelling down the road now apparently being followed by the Brits?
John Lanchester, in his recent essay about Brexit and its impact on the immigration debate in the UK, published in the London Review of Books, argued that,
‘All those millions of our fellow citizens who have spent the last few decades privately muttering to themselves that Enoch had a point now feel empowered, entitled, free to speak their minds at last. There is a real darkness in this country, a xenophobic, racist sickness of heart that is closer to the surface today than it has been for decades. That is a direct result of the referendum campaign. The campaign’s dual legacy is the end of the idea that politics is based on rational argument, and a new permission to hate immigrants’.
The people have it right. In the face of co-ordinated and bipartisan attempts to undermine or destroy nearly everything that made Australia one of the richest and most prosperous countries in history, they have responded in the only way our system really allows: gridlock.
I think you’re cherry-picking data here. Xenophon, who also supported the Senate voting changes benefit by gaining 2 additional seats in the Senate. The net result of the Labor-Greens block is 0, as they maintained the same 35 before and after the election, albeit with some loses and gains in the composition of the members (Greens lost 1, Labor lost one but gained 2 others).
The reason why I highlight this block is because they will be crucial in blocking the ABCC bill, which was the reason the Double Dissolution was triggered in the first place.
Come on Bernard . . . . To best of my knowledge “WE” didn’t have anything to do with this toxic instability engulfing our parliamentary system, beyond exercising our legal responsibility. This crippled Parliament is down to then Opposition Leader Abbott; gained momentum when Immigration Minister Morrison introduced ‘On Water’ unaccountability and politicalization of the public service. Finally, . . . . a coup-de-grace delivered by Prime Minister Turnbull’s double dissolution resulting in an unworkable Senate.
As has been said before; best option is for the Coalition to hire Gillard as a consultant should they actually aspire to governing in the National Interest.
Hire Gillard! +1
Great idea Graybul, but even though Julia could negotiate successfully with pretty much anybody, Talcum’s dysfunctional team would thwart her…..
Can we all finally agree that Turnbull is an overated spiv who has an acumen deficiency the size of Uluru.. His one seat majority was probably purchased with the $2million he stumped up ..Which makes his disdain for the influence of micro parties look very hypocritical.. So far his gifts to the nation include the ruination of the republican cause and the rejuvenation of Hansonite lunacy..
…and not acknowledging we have our own version of Gauntanamo Bay in NT and not closing it down immediately as any humanitarian would do. We are 3u(ked with this mob in control. Front page news around the world!!!!
Can we do a sweepstake on how long Talcum stays leader and a few combo bets on Morrison and Joyce falling by the wayside here on Crikey?