There’d be some justice if the Morrison government was, improbably, re-elected next year. In two shorts months, it has achieved a marvel of political alchemy: the distillation and crystallisation of the worst aspects of modern Australia.
This goes beyond the didja-see-the-footy-don’t-tell-the-wife World’s Straya’s Best Dad persona of Scomo — Scomes, soon, surely? — and his man-of-the-burbs mugging for the cameras. And it goes beyond the way “looking after your mates” is the actual foundational value of his government – whether it’s Stuart Robert, Morrison’s mate who was otherwise inexplicably returned to ministerial status, or the Liberal Party’s fossil fuel industry mates, or the constant pandering to those top Liberal mates, the radio shockjocks and gibbering reactionaries on pay TV.
No, it goes further. Like how the Jerusalem embassy move was an exemplar of that magnificent Australian expression, half-arsed. Like how it represented our reflexive urge to ape America, a reflex that tags us not so much as “deputy sheriff” – our vaulting ambition a decade ago — as Bully Sidekick 3 in small-print B-movie credits. Like how it represented an instinctive comfort with punching down, not up, to show off to our bigger, more brutal mates.
Or while we’re apeing the Yanks, why not steal their cloying, hypocritical humbug toward veterans, a fig leaf of etiquette over a systematic failure to look after the hundreds of thousands of men and women broken by endless pointless wars? Thus yesterday’s weird “announcement” by the government that a private company would be giving priority to veterans and making announcements about them, a sobering display of Respeck for our heroes, a gesture with all the substance of the tinny Made In China Aussie flag lapel pin Morrison tells himself to wear so he can remember which country he’s leading. Never mind that police, and firefighters, and others who sacrifice themselves and their families for others, fly every day and won’t be similarly honoured. It will go nicely with half a billion dollars to be popped out of the Commonwealth ATM for an ever-bigger Canberra temple to the Cult of the Aussie Mars, that minor god famed for his relentless efforts to join in any blue more powerful deities summon him for. Half a billion would go quite some distance to improving mental health services for veterans and ADF personnel, or supporting their families who make considerable sacrifices, but wouldn’t, alas, have the same ribbon-cutting potential. So let us thank them for their service™.
The thought occurs, of course, that one might honour those who serve and those who have served by not being so ready to commit them to pointless wars dictated by US domestic or foreign policy, or an Australian prime minister’s personal inadequacies, or even to have a decision to put them in harm’s way treated as the solemn judgment it is, and have parliament make it. But that would be unAustrayan and wouldn’t fit on a lapel pin.
Or there’s how Morrison’s contretemps with Malcolm Turnbull last week exemplified the lazy bullshittery of Aussie blokes, who find it easier to lie than offer a complicated truth to their mates. The sort of lie easily demonstrated to be exactly that… thus making it more socially acceptable, bullshit as social lubricant. Coupled with the good old-fashioned Aussie anti-intellectualism of Simon Birmingham, boasting of vetoing research grants for topics deemed too intellecktural, and colleague Dan Tehan joining in to threaten adding a “national interest test” to the existing national benefit test relating to grants. Half-arsed, again, and presumably leading the way to research being confined to Fair Dinkum Power, digging shit out of the ground, home brewing and equine sports. Mate.
Then there’s the casual racism of the rejection of the Uluru Statement, and its deliberate misrepresentation, and the use of Indigenous issues – an area of profound policy failure by all sides in Australian politics – as a mechanism in internal Liberal party games, a toy to keep Tones occupied and out of mischief. The racism of people who are mortified and angry if you call them racist, but who won’t look for a moment inside themselves and at their own colonial settler country and its history of dispossession and war. Puddle-deep people leading a country with all those faults but many virtues entirely absent from the circus in Canberra.
Every day confirms that Morriscum is definitely the same dimwit who gave us the “where the bloody hell are ya” campaign.
Oh no Marcus you’ve got the wrong Morrison. This is the smiling genius who held up a lump of coal in Parliament.
I think you’ve covered all the bases nicely Bernard. (Even down to the spelling.) Well done. 🙂
Yep, Bernard seems about as angry as I am. And to think he used to be such an economic rationalist (in old-fashioned speak). How the world turns.
Oh dear, Keane, you’ve become one of THOSE people.
Could we just try supporting a progressive government and an improvement in the media’s coverage of policy before we conclude Australians suck and deserve a horrible government?
The thing which gets me is that the media cheered for the overthrow of Gillard, the installation of “new man” Abbott and his axe the climate change policy, his overthrow by Turnbull, Turnbull beating Shorten in 2016 despite his policies of inequality and not dealing with climate change and all the many many lies and dishonest tactics and dog whistling from the Liberal Party, and now we have cheerful Charlies like Bernard Keane, Katharine Murphy, Tony Wright et al bemoaning the state of our politics, bemoaning the lack of action on climate change, bemoaning the willingness of the Coalition to tolerate white supremacists, the policy on the run… well guess what guys, you collectively gave us this, you don’t get to complain about the Australian people. Even those of you who didn’t editorialise for an Abbott or Turnbull victory (very, very few of you) were pretty shy about calling out the ones who did, weren’t you?
No, what you get to do is a mea culpa. To talk up positive policies that will do good; to talk up adminsitrative competence and unity. To maybe give Shorten and the ALP a fair go – after your misjudgments of Turnbull et al, maybe time to recognise none of you can judge character worth anything and Bill might be much better than you’ve written him off as?
You can whinge about Australians if we elect a Labor government and we get a media that talks about policy rather than an endless stream of bullshit and things are still no different.
All true…and well said, Arky! But expecting the Oz media (including Crikey) to write ANYTHING good about Bill and the ALP? Well that’s just whistling in the wind a bit too hard…..!!
A lot there that I agree with Arky but he did say,”Puddle-deep people leading a country with all those faults but many virtues entirely absent from the circus in Canberra.” As an Aussie and a Muslim who has twice spent years overseas and enjoyed it, but always been glad to come home to Australia, as the father of a young man who has twice been to the US but was glad to come home and never wants to go there again, I would underline the “many virtues entirely absent from the circus in Canberra.”
” . . . well guess what guys, you collectively gave us this”. No, no Arky, the media didn’t elect our politicians, we did. In fact I’d go as far as saying the media didn’t even change our view; we made up our minds ourselves. So who will be whingeing loudest if we next get a hung parliament? It’s what we want isn’t it? It’s the best way to nobble an arrogant major party. But only the voters can make it happen.
Totally agree…tired of eternal blaming of journalists/the media…that’s a cop-out. It’s the voters who elected this government and according to the pollsters, half of them still prefer ScoMo as PM. Too easy blaming the media … these armchair critics/letter writers should instead get off their collective arses and get involved with some grass-roots campaigning.
I’m not saying it’s all the media’s fault, but I’m tired of journalists taking absolutely no responsibility either for the public being uninformed and actively misinformed on many topics. They are hugely responsible for that, through what they cover and what they don’t cover and how they do it.
For example, when every TV talking head and newspaper columnist writes or says that Shorten is untrustworthy, doesn’t cover his good speeches or policy development or unifying his party, only talks about “faceless man”, “union hack”, “zingers” etc literally since he became leader, what a surprise it is that Shorten isn’t popular with a public who knows him almost exclusively through that media coverage, who didn’t even get to see him in campaign debates because Turnbull was a canny coward who didn’t agree to a single debate on free to air TV?
Completely unaccountable, first to complain, and never admitting they’re wrong- the journos and the pollies are good matches for one another. But at least we can vote out the pollies.
I am sure that you appreciate the complications of the mater, Arky, but with all due respect, you seem to be presenting the issue as one-dimensional as
it were. Take a flick through the Oz or The Age of 40 years ago or even 30 years ago. Nowadays (yes -agreed) it is all about subjective reporting. In
the days when public libraries were open only on Saturday mornings (for the working man) obtaining information was difficult although paperbacks were decreasing in price in real terms.
Now, information can be obtained by banging on a keyboard. As Joe-bloke, I’d take the que from News Corp and allow for Orwell being more right than wrong. The country does, in fact, get the politicians that it deserves. The #1 objective of the media is social control and (a short second) community stability. Exceptions occur but they are rare.
I agree that there were far too many msm writers who gave Turnbull too easy a ride. They seemed not to share the great disappointment so many of us felt at his continued failure to press any of the matters we (had deluded ourselves into?) thought he would take on.
They have certainly turned now. But then again – who wouldn’t, given the totally abysmal performance of PM Morrison? Two weeks ago I even read a comment by Michelle Grattan about how tough she had been on PM Gillard – the best PM since PJK in my view. It was in the context of the National Apology to to those who were abused as children, a gathering to which Julia Gillard was warmly received.
I saw that too.
Far too little too late for me to forgive Grattan. She’s in the bad books forever.
Did I miss it or was it just that the one sentence reference in an article in The Conversation about Morrison and Turnbull? Just a bit of generalised pap: “Time gives perspective” stuff. Grattan needs to take out full page ads in all the majors to begin to atone.
I don’t think that I will ever forgive the media for their complicity in the treatment of Julia and the ascendency of Abbott and his carbon tax crap; there seemed to be very few people who were left to be supporters it was so insidious. The ‘wonderful’ Macca had a lot to say, and he seems to hold more weight than Jones and Hadley. (Do you think he will get rid of daylight saving?)
I am pleased that you have called out Morrison for telling lies, everyone else is too ‘polite’ I think.
Hmm, “Bill might be much better …” but the Earth might fall into the Sun with greater likelihood.
You missed a prime chance to use your hilarious nick name for Shorten…small mercies I guess.
Well said! The media need to do their research properly and not to blindly follow the leader. The journalists in USA were so complacent they allowed Trump to become President.
Actually no; in fact absolutely not.
The ONLY publication that did not adopt the line of The Guardian (or, for that matter, Aunty) was the NYT. NOW, with the Republicans having retained the Senate even a fair percentage of the scribblers for Crikey have egg all over their faces (and not for the first time)! In fact the Republicans have done reasonably well (better than expected) with Congress.
The Trump phenomenon is real- whoever begrudges it (as Anne Boleyn quipped on another matter).
Some good things happened here today…not as much as we would have hoped for, but not the carnage I thought would happen, being the cynic I am after 2016. Women, Black women, including Muslim women, got elected to congress, Kris Kobach (he of the voter purging technology) is no longer the governor of Kansas. And here in my state (Oregon), a woman democratic governor defeated a white male Rethug who received $2.5 million from Phil Knight (president of Nike).
I’ll refer you to a blog post from a friend, about what accumulation requires. Yes the Trump threat is real, but it is from Suburbia, not the toothless hillbilly story. And it is more complex.
http://chasinjesus.blogspot.com/2018/11/the-bourgeoisie-is-not-middle-class-and.html
Brilliant Bernard. And right on cue to confirm our worst fears Morrison pops up with ‘the video to Mick Fanning’s mum’.
Gday mate, fair dinkum and the baseball hat all get a run in an excruciating 24 second rant. He’s making Tony Abbott look magisterial in comparison.
“Team Ostrich Needs You!”