In the days after the Christchurch shooting, a nasty trope began to emerge in the far-right online sludge. On a website dedicated to prominent British Islamophobe Tommy Robinson, a local right wing extremist wrote an article arguing that the Greens and other outspoken voices on the left somehow bore responsibility for the terrorist attack through their cultivation of so-called “anti-white racism”.
Within a week, this trope had memed its way into the soundbites of federal MPs, national news sites and live TV. Peter Dutton paved the way last Monday when he claimed the Greens were just as bad as Fraser Anning, the neo-Nazi sympathiser who blamed Muslim immigration for the Christchurch attack.
Deputy Prime Minister Michael McCormack echoed this, arguing they were “much more of a danger to our social fabric than any other party”. Soon, this sentiment had hardened, with Andrew Bolt arguing that the Greens had “blood on their hands” over the Christchurch attack. Then Liberal Party vice-president Teena McQueen accused Greens leader Richard Di Natale of hate speech and inciting violence on ABC’s Q&A. As pressure mounted on Scott Morrison to not preference One Nation following the Al Jazeera sting, at least two Liberal MPs came out arguing that the Greens were in fact the most dangerous political organisation in the country.
This latest round of baffling Greens-bashing, as opposed to genuine policy disagreement, points to two prominent themes in the discourse of the Australian right. Firstly, it shows how quickly talking points from the internet’s reactionary basement enter into mainstream political discourse. Second, it is another example of a recurring tactic on the right: blame the Greens for everything — from natural disasters to regional poverty.
From the sewer to Senate
The “Greens did Christchurch” trope is an almost textbook example of the life cycle of a far-right meme. The meme will usually originate on message boards or ad-riddled right-wing “news” sites before eventually being picked up by News Corp culture warriors and metastasizing into the language of mainstream politicians who give it oxygen and legitimacy.
The recent history of Australian politics is littered with other examples of the pipeline between the right-wing trollosphere and parliament.
Pauline Hanson’s Senate motion, saying “it’s OK to be white” referenced a phrase which originated on neo-Nazi message boards. Liberal senators decided to vote in favour of it, though they later said it was because of an “administrative error”.
Earlier in the year, Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton was reportedly considering fast-tracking visas for white South African farmers who he argued faced persecution and violence. Many in the right-wing media agreed that this was a troubling instance of “reverse racism”. But this sudden concern for white South African farmers didn’t happen overnight. Instead, it has been mobilised as part of a conspiratorial alt-right narrative about white genocide. Within months Donald Trump was also talking about the farmers.
Some talking points are now so ubiquitous among figures on the Australian right, their deeply troubling origins are all but forgotten. The myth that Western culture is under siege from a shadowy cabal of “cultural Marxists”, which has its origins in an anti-Semitic conspiracy theory about Jewish academics, has enthralled people like Nine political editor Chris Uhlmann and Australian Conservatives leader Cory Bernardi. Norwegian far-right mass shooter Anders Breivik was also a believer.
When in doubt, blame the Greens
The post-Christchurch blame game also highlights the often absurd lengths many on the right go to to blame the Greens for, well, almost everything. News Corp columnist Miranda Devine particularly excels. In 2009, then writing in The Sydney Morning Herald, she blamed “greenies” for the Black Saturday bushfires, a claim she has repeatedly come back to, and which she still stood by 10 years later.
Their environmental stance, particularly opposition to mining and push for renewable energy, is frequently blamed for potentially destroying industries, and impoverishing regional Australia.
Wannabe Liberal MP Warren Mundine accused them of being determined to keep poor people poor by opposing mining. When mining giant Glencore announced it would not be opening new coal mines because of climate-related risks, Coalition MPs blamed “latte-sipping Greens” for attempting to destroy the mining industry. Meanwhile, stance on Israel has seen them labelled “a party of ignorant extremists”. Recently, Dutton claimed activist group GetUp, which is campaigning to unseat him, was controlled by the Greens.
This week’s anti-Greens attacks are hardly new for the Coalition. Partly this is a standard form of political deflection. But the combination of “extremely online” right-wing fragments and latent anti-Greens sentiment made it an irresistible bit of political posturing for many on the right.
For those “talking points” to get to the “internet’s reactionary basement”, wouldn’t they have to go in through the conservatiove ground floor?
Sorry, but what is the structure of their particular ‘argument’ here that the Greens caused ChCh? It’s not laid out in the article, but is it just Anning’s argument slightly rephrased? That is, the Greens are anti-white and that persecution has caused the white shooter to run amok – is that it? Sorry to be so dense, but I’m genuinely confused at the causal link they’re suggesting!
You have the entire thing already, yes- the idea that the Greens and other left wingers incite these white supremacists to violence by oppressing them by being “anti-white”.
And because they view the greens as being pro Muslim immigration, that are essentially saying that the Muslim community has it coming. The Right are parasites
This article is extremely biased. The ‘prominent British Islamophobe Tommy Robinson’ has more credibility than any mainstream media organisation you can name. Dare to watch how he destroyed the BBC and note the complete silence from the media. It is called ,Panodrama’ and is a one-hour documentary. Facebook promptly banned him and removed any trace of Panodrama from those who share it. You can find it on tr.news.
You are careful not reference your work:-“On a website dedicated to prominent British Islamophobe Tommy Robinson, a local right-wing extremist wrote.” You are referring to Avi Yemini on TR.NEWS. Avi has just destroyed Comedy Central’s, Jim Jefferies too. In a typical media blackout, they have ignored it.
Google will bury all this too. So much for free speech.
How does it feel to be so brainwashed and to devote your life to hating people?
No Arky I don’t hate anybody, but how would you feel if I commenced my reply, “Arky, the far left Australian idiot”.?
If you remain ignorant of the truth about Tommy Robinson and Avi Yemini, do yourself a favour and catch up on the facts, as 1.5 million Brits do without the need to see mainstream media. You won’t look so silly. See TR.NEWS
Yemini is a sick joke and Yaxley- Lennon has no value, he is pissing in the wind
Yemini is a sick joke and Yaxley- Lennon has no value, he is pissing in the wind
What credibility? The Greens do not promote race hate. Give examples of this paranoid fantasy- I have found no evidence whatsoever.
Very interesting that hate speech is continuing from the extreme right since Christchurch. The Greens are not perfect, but it does not ring true that they have set out to promote racism or violence.
There is a difference between ideology and science; the LNP do not seem to understand that.
The science disciplines of Physics, Chemistry, Oceanography, Astro Physics, Glaciology et al underpin the science of climate change. The science puts a slash through development under all circumstances that the extreme right promote.
The IPCC says we have 12 years to act very quickly. At the time of the Paris Accord it was stated very clearly that the promises made at that time were only the beginning of much more forceful action needed.
Ice cores from past eras show how abrupt climate change can happen in a decade, the view has been stated by Dr Richard Alley.
Smoke; mirrors; deflection.
Anything to distract from the realities of the malfeasance of the “right”.
People are essentially tribal/herd animals, strongly affected by the prevailing winds of popular opinion; opinion which is invariably formed by skilled writers and publishers in the right-wing media.
C’mon, folks – you are being succesfully conned by those who wish to use you up for their own benefit.