The alleged racial abuse aimed Indian players at the Sydney Cricket Ground (SCG) on Sunday is just the latest incident in Australia’s various sporting codes. There is an investigation ongoing into the precise nature of the incident, but Australia’s history gives us no reason to doubt the Indian players’ claims.
To pick a handful of incidents: bananas were thrown at West Indian-born Englishman Gladstone Small (which would be echoed nearly 30 years later in the treatment of AFL player Eddie Betts); the “go home curry munchers” banners; the hectoring of Adam Goodes for having the temerity to point out racial slurs.
Late last year, following criticism of the Australian cricket team’s decision not join global support for the Black Lives Matter movement, star player Pat Cummins admitted the team hadn’t done enough to combat racism.
Of course, Australia is far from the only country to wrestle with racism in sport.
Racial abuse has increased at UK football games — ironically, this has largely been in response to the league’s support of the Black Lives Matter movement. European football has been rife with abuse for a long time. Even Indian players themselves have been accused of using racial slurs.
Victoria University Institute for Health and Sport research fellow Matthew Klugman tells Crikey that there isn’t a lot of research comparing Australian sports fans to those in other countries.
“Obviously it’s a difficult thing to objectively quantify — a lot depends on which players speak up and the culture of the of the players in different leagues,” he said.
“But it’s fair to say Australian cricket is still a place of systemic racism — as is Australia at large, the fan culture just reflects this.”
There is a real dearth of research into systemic racism in Australian cricket, Western Sydney University Institute for Culture and Society associate Dr Keith Parry says.
“In terms of Australian cricket, there is not much research on it generally,” he said. “However, the culture of cricket in Australia is deeply rooted in traditional (masculine) Australian values and these are heavily influenced by Anglo-Celtic ideals that make the acceptance of those that do not fit with these harder. The lack of diversity within national cricket sides may be an indicator that there is still work to be done on the culture of the sport.”
Klugman agreed that race was woven into the origins of cricket.
“In the mid to late 1800s there were lots of concerns about white men not being able to survive Australia’s climate — worries they were too weak,” he said.
“So when they started beating England in the cricket, it uplifted white men in Australia, convinced them they were just as good and strong as white men in England. The sense that sport redeems white Australia was there, and elements of that remain to this day.”
University of the Sunshine Coast researcher David Utting examined how Cricket Australia until very recently aligned itself with Howard-era notions of Anglo-Australia rather than embracing multiculturalism. Utting notes that between 1946 and 2015, there were only 10 Test players for the Australian men’s team whose lineage was not ultimately British.
Even since then, players like Usman Khawaja have criticised Cricket Australia’s approach to multiculturalism and race.
“The sense that cricket lags even behind other codes [on issues of race] is probably true. Historically it’s been a much whiter sport than the various football codes,” Klugman said.
“So that may be why the lack the language to acknowledge the systemic nature of these problem.
“They’ve been doing some work, for example bringing in the Johnny Muller medal, but there’s a long way to go.”
We are a racist country. Always have been.
Is any country not?
Yes but we have our very own unigue home grown Australian form of racism..So no need to be culturally cringing about it with what about the rest of the world deflections..It’s our history ..own it like you would naturally own a piece of property..
I just don’t like negative stereotypes about whole groups of people.
Humans are all racist. It is in our biology. We are supposed to use our frontal cortex and logical reasoning skills to recognise it and expunge it.
One was visiting Australia during the 2007/8? cricket test series vs. India, could not believe the ugly noise directed at the Indian team, including the broad media and social narratives, backgrounded by Indian students being attacked and becoming an international issue (most Australians unaware, but embarrasing to see miral and ethical friends dribbling at the mouth about Indians or cricketer Singh….).
A comment above states: ‘Does anyone remember Harbijan Sing’s sledging of Andrew Symons?’ Not sure that justifies anything, except simply being an example of ‘whataboutery’ to deflect criticism?
Not only did the Australian cricket team used sledging aggressively, much of it was racially based e.g. former English captain Ramprakash only ever faced racial slurs from the Australian team, why?
Net result, like AFL, cricket has used trite ‘Australian values’, ‘Anazackery’, macho behaviour etc. to promote their codes to mostly ageing declining Anglo/Irish demographics with dollops of exceptionalism, while Rugby Union is on life support.
Johnny Mullagh
Indeed we could at least spell the old mate’s name correctly.
As you say India has its own share of racist issues at home, not to mention the castes. Cricket does not allow indigenous pride the way that the footy codes do (the game, not the sport itself). You can’t really display like Goodes every wicket. I have met plenty of Indian players at the local level and they have not had much cheek. The most perceptive analyst of the one day game I have met was a Bangladeshi Australian called Rasib. I have also heard racist remarks about my Indian colleagues, (not by other colleaugues) but they are unusual. Unfortunately, our nation’s leaders spruik the white man’s tale as a matter of course since Little Johnny’s time and January is the worst month for them. Most Blackfellas I know just want respect for who they are and understanding of what changed when. I have mates whose parents were stolen generation, kids were taken still in my time. Tim Paine might need to read “What the Colonists Never Knew” (all sports administrators should have to.)
There are clearly many fans of various sports who are prepared to use racist heckling to upset opposition players. They should be called out for it by other spectators, players of both sides and officials and this is happening more frequently.
Whether the actions of a very small minority of fans at the SCG justify the conclusion that Australia is a ‘racist country’ is another matter.