Fiona Scott had a sinking feeling the moment then Liberal leader Tony Abbott opened his mouth and described her as having “a little sex appeal” during the 2013 federal election campaign.
“I was in a bit of shock and I went home and I thought ‘this is going to really hurt tomorrow’,” Scott recalled. And it did. The “sex appeal” label made her life a misery on the campaign trail. “It served to frame me in a way that gave people open slather to talk about my looks,” she told Crikey. Punters threw the word back at her. But that was just the beginning.
After winning her western Sydney seat in the 2013 Abbott-slide and heading to Canberra, Scott found the label had stuck within the party and the parliament. “I was starting a long way back because of predisposed views,” she reflected.
She recalls in particular the time Queensland LNP member Scott Buchholz ruled her out of having a spot on the powerful House of Representatives economics committee because she wasn’t one of “the big boys” who had PhDs and masters in economics, she says.
Scott recall Buchholz seemed unaware that she held an MBA and had a love of economic policy.
Scott lasted one term and was out in the Turnbull election of 2016.
Within a year, still raw from the ordeal, the departed MP spoke candidly of the “sex appeal” episode on Sky News, where she became a commentator. She told the Buchholz story but she cautioned then and now that the Liberal man problem was not the only factor.
The “elite left”, as she calls them, had magnified her problems by creating an altered version of a widely published photo of Abbott standing next to Scott. The makers of the image had given Scott enlarged breasts — “a boob job that would have cost $20,000 if it was real”, she recalls — and had photoshopped Abbott’s head such that he no longer looked at her face but peered deep into her (false) cleavage. The image went crazy. And it hurt Scott deeply.
“What I find objectionable is that this was a photo where a woman was objectified. I didn’t ask to be objectified. My family had to see it. And it was retweeted by people who consider themselves progressives and feminists just to get Tony Abbott,” she told Crikey. Later, she would also have to hear former Labor leader Mark Latham on radio deride her by saying you needed “the beer goggles on” to think Scott had “sex appeal”. The episode has echoes of the campaign trail abuse suffered by South Australia Liberal MP Nicolle Flint, who has decided to quit politics altogether.
The issues confronting the Morrison government, Scott believes, are not confined to the Liberal party. “It’s far broader than that, and the opportunity for parliament is to take the leadership position to guide Australia to the culture and society that we want.”
Fiona Scott’s story represents, at the very least, a clear calling out of sexist behaviour by some sections of the Liberal party in 2017. It is also significant that Scott is prepared to speak about it publicly despite holding a board appointment at the National Film and Sound Archive, courtesy of then Arts Minister Mitch Fifield.
The role comes with a $22,000 annual fee — a relatively low amount compared to some other appointments. Scott acknowledges the perception that the appointment might hold her back from being critical of the government. But she told Crikey that she felt free to speak on the treatment of women and would do so.
Her final verdict? “I don’t want to see a talented generation of women not go into politics because of what they see happen to people like me and Nicolle Flint.”
Fiona and Nicole suffered flea bites compared to the crocodile savaging of Julia.
Julia was subjected to a horror show, absolutely, but it’s not helpful to employ a “that’s nothing, this is worse” narrative. This is humiliating and career breaking, and who knows what she could have broght to the current government if she wasn’t belittled out of it. They just might be slightly less awful.
I doubt she’d have achieved any change in the Men’s Party. The charade is decades old.
Yes, funny to hear Nicole bemoaning the kind of behaviour that she condoned when it was Abbott doing it.
Back then that was “inspirational”?
So the photo was doctored by the “ elitist left”! No proof. Just an assertion and most likely a crock of crap!
It would be valuable to have the original and the photoshopped version side by side as well as an evidence trail as to who was responsible.
Ha ha, you expect ot get PROOF from a member of the hard right?
It’s what happens when you the elite left do your wardrobe…..
Then she pops up on SKY “News(?)” as a “commentator”?
…. As for those allegations of Flint’s (re her being stalked) – the “reason” she’s jumping (not to mention her chances at the next poll)?
“It’s what happens when the elite left do your wardrobe…..”
Surely Australia is better off with both of them not in parliament.
By god the right can whinge! Flint and Scott stood for objectionable, elitist policies and were challenged because of that. The right hate being questioned, neither of them has an ounce of quality, just a quantity of entitlement.
Where were their qualms about Robodebt and the degradation inherent in that for their ‘lower classes’ – men and women? Refugees? “Andie Fox”?
I suspect Nicolle has cut and run because she has had a peak at the polling, although I am not denying that being a woman in politics is a tough gig – just ask Julia. That said, Flint complaining about people treating her badly because she is a women is a bit rich given that her 2019 campaign manager, advisor and fellow hard right faction member was Sam Duluk, the state member for Waite which takes in some of Flint’s federal seat of Boothby. Duluk was charged with assaulting SA Best MP Connie Bonaros at a 2019 parliamentary Christmas party and will stand trial in June. This link gives some of the details:
https://greekherald.com.au/news/south-australian-mp-faces-trial-in-june-for-allegedly-assaulting-fellow-mp-connie-bonaros/
A further irony for Flint is that if she hadn’t been so hasty and had stuck around, she might have actually benefitted from her gender and have landed herself a spot in the cabinet in the recent reshuffle. After all even Melissa Price got rehired!
Edit: peek
Of course, what nobody has asked is why senior executives had to be especially rewarded for just doing their (already highly remunerated) jobs.
Yes, Holgate was treated appallingly compared to her male counterparts, but she’s still a symptom and not the cause.