In 2017, the NSW Police Force created a special section, the Fixated Persons Investigations Unit (FPIU). Its remit, as advertised, was to plug a growing and scary gap in policing: lone-wolf violent (or potentially violent) offenders who have been showing signs of dangerous extremism but fall short of the threshold for terrorism.
The target market, we were told, were the (mostly) men we traditionally refer to as “crazies”. Individuals who have become obsessed with a single mad idea, a group in society or another person, and who are at risk of turning that obsession into acts of violence. An example might have been the man whose actions were part of the reason for the unit’s creation: Man Haron Monis, the Lindt cafe gunman.
Two years after its formation, the FPIU had reportedly completed more than 100 investigations, charged 40 people and seized 31 firearms. It was, we were told, working well and achieving its purpose. Mostly below the public radar, manning the wall that enables us to sleep.
No argument with that, provided the unit operates within the law and does not fall into one of the two obviously tempting traps that lie always open when law enforcement expands its traditional reach. The first trap is that of taking on extrajudicial function — judge, jury and executioner. The second is that of being co-opted by government for political purposes.
Sadly, the FPIU has just fallen headfirst into trap number two, thanks to some presumably lax internal governance by the NSW Police but also (and mostly) due to the extraordinary arrogance of the NSW Deputy Premier John Barilaro.
Jordan Shanks, aka Friendlyjordies, the YouTube citizen journalist and professional provocateur, is plenty controversial and has some questionable attitudes. However, he is a legitimate and effective participant in what passes for our free press. His main thing is holding power to account, which he does with passion, some acerbic humour and pretty deep research.
One of his big targets has been Barilaro, who he’s been going after for some time. Barilaro is now suing him for defamation, claiming he’s been unfairly labelled as corrupt. That’s just de rigueur for Coalition politicians these days, it’d be disappointing if he wasn’t suing.
Things went crazy earlier this week when Shanks’ producer, Kristo Langker, age 21, was arrested at his home by NSW Police officers and charged with two counts of stalking Barilaro.
The stalking charges — technically, “stalk or intimidate intending to cause fear of physical or mental harm” — relate to two recent incidents. The first happened at Macquarie University, where Barilaro was attending an event. Shanks had been there, making a lot of noise about why Barilaro is suing him, then left. Allegedly, Langker remained, continuing to shout at Barilaro while physically trying to get close to him.
The second incident was, according to Langker, a coincidence. He happened upon Barilaro in the city, and approached him, again asking why the lawsuit. Barilaro got in his car and drove off. That one was all captured on video by Langker himself.
As to whether Langker’s actions were stalking or an exercise of his constitutionally protected freedom of political communication, Chaser-style, that we can leave to the local court.
The real point of interest is the fact that the police who turned up at Langker’s home, arrested him and carted him off to spend a night in the cells before being granted bail, were plain-clothes members of the FPIU driving an unmarked car.
What is it about Langker’s actions that could, on any basis, bring him within the definition of a “fixated person”? If anyone is “fixated” on John Barilaro, it’s Shanks, albeit only in the sense that he clearly thinks Barilaro is a fair target for vituperative criticism and allegations of wrongdoing in the execution of his office of high public trust. You know, free press.
As for Langker, assuming he has committed an act of stalking in the criminal sense (OK, it’s a stretch), it’s difficult to see even then how that adds up to anything that would have justified more than a summons to appear before a magistrate, like they used to do to the Chaser boys when they annoyed John Howard a little too much.
It didn’t, we can safely agree, call for a paramilitary response. It didn’t call for the kind of police operation we are assured is reserved for actually dangerous predators who present a clear and present danger to the public. It didn’t call for the kind of thing we occasionally remind ourselves is what they used to do in Chile, or currently do in the Philippines.
Dragging people off the street into unmarked vehicles is what they do in, well, China. But of course, that’s not us.
But it is.
Did NSW Police go too far? Send your thoughts to letters@crikey.com.au. Please include your full name to be considered for publication in Crikey’s Your Say section.
Is this what the Civil libertarians warned of when powers were given for ‘terrorism related activities’? Politicians should not be able to use them to avoid embarrassment from satire and accountability
I absolutely agree.
But I remember that my old Scots Gran, who had a fund of sayings and could produce an apt one for every event or occasion, always said it took grace to be embarrassed. If you can find a single fibre of grace anywhere within the current Australian political class you must be using an electron microscope.
And Barilaro must certainly be amongst the most graceless.
But if the politician is terrified of being satirised and Jordies satirised him, isn’t that terrorism? Or if he’s terrified of being criticised…. Or if he’s terrified of being looked at sideways…
We don’t have civil libertarians, just uncivil ones and the only liberty they’re interested in is their own. Did someone say “Leyonhjelm”?
As for the LNP, it’s Australia’s most prominent and successful fascist organisation. And racist to the core.
I agree, as satirically as I lawfully can
Thank you, Crikey and Michael Bradley, for giving this incident the public air it deserves. Australia seems to be sliding with increasing rapidity into the kind of place where people can be quietly disappeared if they happen to disapprove of the way the government, or members of the government, behave. It is most disconcerting that this kind of treatment can be meted out to a young man exercising his right to complain of governmental action.
Yes and the gullible public voted Scomo back in..I think we need to take a good hard look at ourselves and see that we have sadly become inherently selfish as well..
C’mon, PC. We are among the select who subscribe to sensible journalism. So this is not so much about “ourselves” but about the gullible voters you refer to. We don’t need the introspection; time for us to start raising our voices and broaching the subject of our freedoms with our neighbours. These pollies are out of control as a result of being endorsed by the hoi polloi.
I agree but some serious self-reflection is required on our behalf.. People vote out of self-interest from the left and right now..Your comment also reeks of elitism as well because Australians don’t like being challenged for their shortcomings and they get defensive especially amongst the bourgeois.
Thanks for the heads up. I was unaware of my odour!
https://www.statista.com/statistics/892461/australia-paid-online-news-consumption-by-age/
France, Greece .. and many other countries voters are much more switched on than the smug complacency of your comment and that of your fellow citizens.
I suggest political dialog with our neighbours / local communities = reeking of elitism and smug complacency. OK, PC, that’s a little ironic but I apologise if you find that suggestion so offensive.
What total garbage, PC. I am a high-income earner, with no kids and no health issues. If I were motivated solely by self interest, I’d vote Liberal every single time. Yet myself, and all my friends and colleagues, are completely put off by the hatred and naked corruption of the Liberal and National Party-so always vote for Greens or Labor. BTW, you cannot get more “elite” than the Coalition and their donors…..yet Murdoch (another “elite”) gets the great unwashed to vote for them on a regular basis.
Research in the US suggests voters vote primarily out of a sense of shared values. That suggests a lot of horrible people in Oz but possibly the kinder explanation is they live in the fear and outrage bubble created by Murdoch and MSM, and of course by the simple minded, foul language echo chamber on FB/Twitter and they have a naive trust in wealthy people. Lot of dumb folks in any population being played and a woeful opposition comms strategy.
Furthermore the shit has to hit the perverbial fan for Australians to take notice..Sexual assaults in Parliament is a classic case in point…We ALWAYS leave it too late as we are selfish,privileged and complacent..Many cultural norms have to change ..Today’s news-poll sees Dan Andrews ratings drop in Victoria and a possible change of leadership with Victorian Liberals to win the next election..Scomo’s team are ruthless Watch this space.
‘These pollies are out of control as a result of being endorsed by the hoi polloi.’
This is very much the case, Lord Muck. We are not yet a dictatorship. Some of these pollies seem to think they can act like little Putins.
These Liberal/National types dish out abuse after abuse but all have glass jaws if anyone returns serve. Free speech my sweet ass.
Yes, I just did a quick Google search, to see if I could find any comments, by the right wing talking heads, who love to portray themselves as champions of free speech and who are forever gibbering on about cancel culture. Of course, there doesn’t seem to be a peep from News Corpse columnists, talkback radio blowhards or publicity hungry LNP hacks. Which is totally to be expected. An actual attack on political freedom: crickets. Mr Potatohead possibly being rebranded as Potatohead: they’re all over it.
So Micallif had better watch his back?
Turning that focus – what are the chances this “task farce” could be set on those politicians and their PS flunkies that harass innocent tax-payers…..
On Micallif, has anyone noticed that the closed captions are wildly out of synch with the spoken word, to the extent all the punch lines are ruined? Same with Charlie Pickering, and both these shows are scripted. More unstructured, apolitical, shows like Hard Quiz aren’t sabotaged in this way. This government is making me paranoid, and that seems the only rational response.
It is perfectly correct to feel paranoid if your behaviour really is being observed by another person or persons unknown.
Back in 2002 an American citizen, José Padilla, was pronounced fit to stand trial by a court psychiatrist who said that after 1307 days of torture by US authorities, “He does believe that he is being persecuted by the government, and he does demonstrate some paranoia about the government, but this does not appear to be delusional.”
I also rely on subtitle and have noticed it too. I complained to ABC about this delay a couple of years ago – from memory it was also in relation to Mad as Hell. They denied it was a problem, and it went away shortly after. Might be worth another gripe.
Anyone who is not paranoid isn’t paying attention.
Wow, where do you start with the NSW cops? They were completely out of control during the 70s and 80s, more dangerous than the crooks. Then they were partly pulled into line by the 90s Royal Commission, which amusingly coincided with Bob Carr’s law and order campaign. Now, despite their abject failure in the Martin Place seige, they are out of control again, less corrupt and crook but more political, always backed by their minister, still investigating themselves and always on the lookout for political brownie points.
It is not just the cops. The Libs, the Nats and the ALP in NSW do not inspire any confidence in me. The daily evidence of the lack of both honesty and integrity in all NSW political parties I find quite staggering.
Yes, I think law enforcement in NSW, has had its issues since around 1788.
Ditto for the Federal Government.
Their various embodiments of that rum cause always been a problem.
While Mick Fuller takes out Morrison’s ‘trash’ – both physically and metaphorically.
Scotty’s ‘bin man’ would have suggested this action… knows calling in the Fixated Person’s Unit would make it more serious to the ‘Quiet Aussies’…