AIR OF RESIGNATION
Christian Porter has resigned from federal cabinet, resisting growing pressure to reveal more information about the source of the funds in the “blind trust” used to pay for part of his legal fees. At a hastily called press conference on Sunday afternoon, Prime Minister Scott Morrison said that Porter’s decision to step down was, in fact, upholding the ministerial standards that he had been accused of breaking.
Shortly after the presser, Porter released a 1600 word screed — err, statement — explaining his decision to step down. In it, he takes aim at the ABC and the “Twitter mob” for promoting an allegation he denies while also arguing that he has met the requirements of his office.
Angus Taylor will temporarily take over Porter’s science and industry portfolio, but the Member for Pearce maintains that he will re-contest his seat at the next federal election.
[free_worm]
SUB-OPTIMAL RECEPTION
The fallout from Australia’s nuclear sub deal continues. A jilted France recalled its ambassadors to Australia and the US for the first time ever, Bloomberg reports, although the UK was spared. The BBC says that France was informed about the deal “only hours” before the public announcement was made. French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian slammed the decision saying “You can’t play that way in an alliance”. Defence Minister Peter Dutton, for what it’s worth, reckons Australia has been “upfront, open and honest” throughout the whole proceedings, according to The Australian.
Meanwhile, the ABC reports that Trade Minister Dan Tehan will go to France in the next fortnight to try and mend fences as the government fears that France’s snubbing will harm trade talks with the EU. Indonesia, however, is off the government’s itinerary as Sky News says that Morrison will cancel a planned meet-and-greet with President Joko Widodo, who has raised concerns about Australia’s nuclear submarine intentions.
THE LIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL
Victorian Premier Dan Andrews released the state’s roadmap out of lockdown on Sunday, giving dates and targets for the lifting of public health restrictions and the granting of freedoms to the vaccinated. “Make no mistake, we are opening this place up. There is no alternative,” Andrews said, dispelling the beliefs of those few still holding onto the idea of a COVID elimination strategy. But there is still quite some darkness to go through yet. Such a strategy will have a better than one-in-two chance of exceeding the state’s hospital and ICU capacity and could lead to the deaths of more than 3000 people, Nine reports.
This brings Victoria more or less into line with NSW which is going full speed ahead toward its own re-opening plans. On Friday, updated Doherty Institute modelling warned that medium measures — which, in the past, meant stay-at-home orders for anything than work, study, and other essential purposes — would be “prudent” until Australia hits 80% vaccination if there’s high case numbers, according to Guardian Australia. Australian Medical Association president Dr Omar Khorshid told AAP that this updated modelling shows a need for patience: “When implementing the national plan we must be realistic, careful and test each change and the impact of measures before moving to the next phase, given that there are thousands of COVID-19 cases in the community.”
TECH TIME
Since I’ve wrestled control of this newsletter for one edition, I wanted to put my own spin on it by adding a tech news kicker. And boy, do we have a whopper: The Wall Street Journal dropped the Facebook Files, an incredible series of pieces that delve into the dark side of the Mark Zuckerberg-led company.
Drawing on never-before-seen internal documents from the company, the WSJ lays out the devastating impact of the tech giant. The company’s top accounts are exempted from many of the rules (like when international soccer star Neymar posted naked images of a woman who accused him of rape to the platform, he suffered no consequences). Vaccine misinformation is so rife on the platform that a fifth of all vaccine-related posts were found to be anti-vaxx. Internationally, sex trafficking rings allegedly use Facebook to organise their efforts with impunity — and when Facebook found this out, they reportedly removed the content but failed to inform law enforcement. Taken in full, the investigation shows a company that prioritises growth above all else — even their users’ safety.
OK, talk to you on Tuesday.
SAY WHAT?
Friday’s official figures showed we have so far stuck 34,911,907 testing strips up people’s noses, to discover around 80,000 positive cases. That means 34.8 million of those tests were unnecessary; so at more than $100 each, we’ve spent $3.5bn on literally nothing.
Steve Waterson
There were a few heads being scratched when the Commercial Editor for The Australian Steve Waterson weighed into the debate about the economic expense of lockdowns. In a wide ranging piece — that at one point compares the public health measures to the Nazi Germany regime, before conceding that this broke Godwin’s law — Waterson makes the case that COVID-19 tests are only useful when they detect the virus. Hey, maybe we should start screening people for the virus before we test them…
CRIKEY RECAP
Brian Houston steps aside from Hillsong’s boards as his day in court looms
“Pastor Brian Houston, whose name is synonymous with the Hillsong megachurch, has stepped aside from virtually all his directorships in Hillsong entities in a major corporate overhaul before he is due to face criminal charges of concealment early next month.
“A friend and mentor to Prime Minister Scott Morrison, Houston has been a fixture on the boards of Hillsong entities — in some cases for more than two decades. Over that period Hillsong has grown exponentially from its base in Sydney’s north-west to become a global phenomenon.”
Morrison’s mates find a lucrative opportunity amid the pandemic
“Is the talent pool in Canberra getting smaller? The latest company with plans to cash in on the pandemic has ties to the Morrison government — and some familiar names are popping up again.
“There are also questions about whether the group’s close political ties create a conflict of interest. All business ventures benefit from good political connections, and QSA has them in spades.”
We found the PM’s Facebook and Instagram accounts. That’s a national security risk
“The accounts, while partially locked down, reveal information about Morrison and his close contacts, making them a potential national security issue.
“He’s lashed out at Facebook before, saying its decision to temporarily ban news — or ‘unfriend Australia’ as he called it — was arrogant. Despite this, Morrison is an avid user of it and Instagram to promote himself and his political causes. Now we know he continues to use it personally as well.”
READ ALL ABOUT IT
‘Killed like animals’: documents reveal how Australia turned a blind eye to a West Papuan massacre (Guardian Australia)
Abandoned overseas: The mental health toll of Australia’s closed borders on its citizens (SBS)
Nike and Amazon among brands advertising on COVID conspiracy sites (The Guardian)
Pentagon acknowledges August 29 drone strike in Afghanistan was a tragic mistake that killed 10 civilians (The New York Times)
Glasgow climate summit at risk of failure, UN chief warns (Al Jazeera)
Israel reportedly used a remote-controlled gun to assassinate an Iranian scientist (Engadget)
El Salvador’s Bitcoin law is a farce (Foreign Policy)
Man leaves Westmead Hospital after fighting COVID-19 for 399 days
THE COMMENTARIAT
Australia’s foreign policy is getting clumsy and arrogant — Anthony Galloway (The SMH): “Australia’s actions right now have serious implications on the world stage and there are questions about whether our diplomacy has been strong enough to support our strategic intentions.
“Any criticism of the government’s handling of these announcements is always met with astonishment. It’s like the government is playing chess and the rest of us are playing checkers; we shouldn’t have the temerity to question their brilliance. Increasingly, other countries are questioning it.”
AUKUS alliance: French submarine fury is a farce — Greg Sheridan (The Australian) ($): “Their reaction, in fact, is so over the top and ridiculous, so full of petty insult and juvenile foot-stamping that it probably confirms just what a mistake it was ever to get so deeply involved with the French in strategic matters in the first place.
“The French shoulder a large share of blame for not keeping their customer happy. On the other hand, they found our Defence Organisation slow, liable to change requirements and difficult to deal with in numerous other ways. The Australian performance at every stage of this submarine saga has been woeful … but the French reaction remains absurd and does them no credit.”
HOLD THE FRONT PAGE
WHAT’S ON TODAY
Australia
-
Prime Minister Scott Morrison will travel to the US ahead of Quad leaders’ summit.
New York, London
-
Vigils for Australians stranded abroad are being held as organisers say there has been a failure to protect citizens abroad and at home through lack of fit quarantine facilities and a slow vaccine rollout.
Christian Porter has resigned from the frontbench rather than disclosing who paid for part of his legal fees…Shortly after the presser, Porter released a 1600 word screed — err, statement — explaining his decision to step down. In it, he takes aim at the ABC and the “Twitter mob” …
Good riddance, but he must be expelled from Parliament.
Word is that his good mate Twiggy No Tax Paid by Me for 16 years Forrest came to his rescue
Forrest has no doubt done a cost-benefit analysis of his donation to Porter’s legal fees, and decided the potential benefits outweigh the costs.
Morri$sinner on Porter having to do a McKenzie stint on the back bench, through no fault of his own mind you, is Scovid at his deceitful best :
“The inability for him to be able to practically provide further information..”
Here Scovid let me help you with the truth – with which you have never been acquainted:
“The refusal by Porter to out his cash cow bagman…if he were able to do that,”
All those years subscribing and tithing to bulls***, it all comes second nature for you, or did Phil come up with that, or more than likely the disembler Porter did!
“The refusal by Porter to out his cash cow bagman…if he so chose but refuses to do,”
There fixed it finally for you Psycho Morri$sinner
And are only Ministers required to meet a (very vague) code of conduct? Hiss and spit. I really, really hope this is not over yet.
Joyce expects former federal minister Christian Porter to one day return to the frontbench
Here’s your answer. Howard’s standard reigns unchallenged
Minister Jim Short was forced to resign for failing to divest himself of financial interests in his area of ministerial responsibility.
Industry minister John Moore was exposed for his shareholdings in technology investment and share-trading companies.
Parliamentary secretary Brian Gibson lost his job because of a conflict of interest.
Small business minister Geoff Prosser was running three shopping centres while he was a minister and he was forced to resign.
Resources minister Warwick Parer had massive share interests in a coalmine and in other resource companies; he stayed, in breach of the ministerial code.
Acting minister for communications Peter McGauran forgot that he owned 70 poker machines.
Employment services minister Mal Brough promoted training courses which were actually Liberal Party fundraisers.
Industry minister Ian Macfarlane was involved in a complex scam to rort GST rebates from Liberal Party fundraisers.
Aboriginal affairs minister John Herron kept up his practice as a surgeon, in breach of the code.
Mr Howard himself was found to be in breach of his own code when he failed to resign as a director of the Menzies Research Centre. Mr Howard misled the parliament over meetings he had held with ethanol producer Manildra’s boss – massive Liberal Party donor Dick Honan. It was eventually proved that the meetings did occur, and three weeks later the government increased trade penalties against a Brazilian ethanol producer.
Parliamentary secretary Warren Entsch’s concrete company won a massive government contract in breach of the code.
Peter Reith was appointed as a consultant to defence contractor Tenix immediately after resigning as defence minister.
Health minister Michael Wooldridge signed a $5 million building deal for the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners and days later, after resigning as health minister, was employed by the college as a consultant.
Senator Coonan, as Minister for Revenue, avoided paying a land tax. She was then exposed and forced to resign as a registered director of an insurance dispute resolution company operating from her own home.
Wilson Tuckey, then Minister for Regional Services, Territories and Local Government, heavied a state police minister on behalf of a family member.
Parliamentary secretary Bob Woods retired from politics when he was under police investigation for travel rorts.
Communication minister Richard Alston’s family trust held Telstra shares.
Peter Costello, the Treasurer, appointed Liberal Party megadonor Robert Gerard to the Reserve Bank board despite being told by Mr Gerard that he was involved in a 14-year-long tax evasion dispute with the Australian Taxation Office.
Three ministers – John Sharp, David Jull and Peter McGauran – were forced to resign as a result of travel rorts involving false claims, mismanagement or cover-ups.
Parliamentary secretary Bill Heffernan was forced to resign over fabricated claims against a High Court judge.
Howard gave Australia 10 years of public policy failure.
Then Howard relented, changed the Min Code of Conduct so those types of transgressions were not sackable, and the rest is history.
Coalition corruption
MPs forced out of parliament or the party:
Liberal Premier Barry O’Farrell (Liberal, NSW)
Scott Driscoll (Liberal National, QLD)
Troy Buswell (Liberal, WA)
Chris Spence (Liberal, NSW)
Darren Webber (Liberal, NSW)
Gary Edwards (Liberal, NSW)
Andrew Cornwell (Liberal, NSW)
Tim Owen (Liberal, NSW)
Craig Baumann (Liberal, NSW)
Bart Bassett (Liberal, NSW)
Peter Dowling (Liberal National, QLD)
Marie Ficarra (Liberal, NSW)
Liberal Staffers:
Ray Carter
Timothy Koelma
MPs sacked from executive government:
Greg Pearce (Liberal, NSW)
Mike Gallacher (Liberal, NSW)
Chris Hartcher (Liberal, NSW)
Jamie Briggs (Liberal, Federal)
Stuart Robert (Liberal, Federal)
MPs stood aside from executive government:
Mal Brough (Liberal, Federal)
Arthur Sinodinos (Liberal, Federal)
MPs forced to resign from the Highest Office, Speaker of the House of Reps:
Bronwyn Bishop (Liberal, Federal)
MPs assisting police with their inquiries:
Christopher Pyne (Liberal, Federal)
Wyatt Roy (Liberal, Federal)
Mal Brough (Liberal, Federal)
Arthur Sinodinos (Liberal, Federal)
Get the sick bags ready
Joyce: “I bet you his electorate won’t resign from him though. He’s an incredibly astute politician, he’s incredibly capable.
“I’ll put money that we’ll see him back again.”
Employment Minister Pentecostal Brother Stuart Robert defended Mr Porter as “an incredibly decent and smart operator”.
“He put a statement out yesterday, it’s heartbreaking reading when you look at what he’s been through,” Mr Robert told the Nine Network.
Neither of these two Porter mouthpieces would know a moral or decency if it slapped them in the groin
‘Incredible’ and ‘incredibly’ have become our most overused words. As in ‘he’s an incredibly decent and smart person.’ In other words, he’s so decent and smart, you just cannot believe it!’
If Robert believes Porter’s statement is a ‘heartbreaking read when you look at what he’s been through’, I wonder what he makes of Kate’s dossier of allegations of what Porter did to her, and what she went through.
So interesting to see reaction to Porter’s accepting ‘blind trust’ payment for his legal bills compared with Sam Dastyari’s hounding and subsequent resignation from politics. Obviously both are in the ‘dodgy’ area of potential corruption but only one politician has to leave Parliament. Keeping the donors anonymous then does pay!