Exhibition Park in Canberra hosts car festivals, farmers’ markets and book fairs on its expansive grounds. But this week it’s been taken over by thousands of protesters rallying against vaccine mandates.
Cars — many adorned with merchant navy flags, the Aboriginal flag and signs protesting their cause — are squeezed on to every spare patch of grass, tents and caravans stretching as far as the eye can see.
There’s a community feel. Some campers play live music, others have set up barbecues, and there’s a man selling light-up toys and magician sets. The group is diverse: young and old, a mix of trades and while predominantly white there’s a mix of ethnicities and religions.
Despite the chilly breeze, plenty of people are walking around, beer in one hand and cigarette in the other, in bare feet or thongs. Weed smoke wafts from several campsites. People smile and wave to one another and stop to check in on solo travellers.
Every time a convoy of cars arrives — the last arriving from northern Queensland — passengers toot their horns and stick their heads out the window to whoops and cheers.
But there’s a dark side to the festivities. Many protesters here aren’t just against vaccine mandates. They are actively trying to catch COVID-19 and discourage others from taking the vaccine. Some want to storm Parliament; others want a stop to childhood vaccinations.
The protesters don’t have a clear message: most are against vaccine mandates, some are rallying for Indigenous land rights, and others still believe in a conspiracy alleging Australia’s politicians are part of a widespread paedophile ring.
Michael Simms is one of the few unofficial organisers of the convoy. He runs an organisation called Millions March Against Mandatory Vaccination Australia and was a disability support worker in Canberra before losing his job for refusing to get the vaccine. Simms claims he is the father of a vaccine-injured child.
“There’s no real group [organisers]. That’s a good thing and bad thing,” he said.
He says the movement was grassroots and while he’s enjoying his notoriety for being one of the few known organisers, he didn’t set out for this: “After one truck driver said he was driving to Canberra, things just spiralled.”
While peacekeeper volunteers roam the sites to make sure no one gets too rowdy, there has been plenty of dissent among self-proclaimed organisers. They’re confused about events, fighting over microphones and what their demands even are, with some circulating petitions and others calling for funding with no real goal. (GoFundMe froze access to $160,000 in donated funds due to a lack of detailed spending plan.)
Simms doesn’t like being told what to do. If the vaccine mandates didn’t exist, I ask, would he have been more inclined to get it?
“It would have been more of a thought,” he said.
He believes that although the group lacks clear direction, the community feel is incredibly important.
“For the first time in two years, people have got to leave their state and find people that are kinda like them when their family or friends may have told them ‘You’re nuts’,” he said.
A group of older women sit huddled in a circle, enjoying white wine and conversation. The sun has started to set, turning the sky vivid shades of orange and purple, and they are wrapped in sleeping bags with their camp chairs facing the view. They invite me to sit on their esky and ask questions.
The women met at the campground or on convoys from other parts of Australia. Most were travelling alone. I ask what, aside from anti-vaccine ideals, drew them together.
“A sense of community,” says one, who asked for her name not to be used. “It’s about actually being accepted and loved and being able to speak out without being judged or being harassed or feeling like we have to walk on eggshells.”
Most of the women, who previously worked as phlebotomists, teachers and registered nurses, lost their jobs for refusing to accept the vaccine mandate.
“I lost my purpose in life,” Leigh Riley, who worked as a nurse in Gympie, Queensland, tells me. It sent her spiralling into a dark depression, drinking heavily before finding a community in the anti-mandate movement. Her family won’t see her because of her views.
I ask if she’d been tempted to get the vaccine just to be able to experience family life once again.
“It made me more resolute,” she said. “I believe it’s not good for me, and I believe that so strongly I refuse to get it and I lost my job so there’s no way I’ll backpedal on this.”
It’s an interesting point. For many sucked into the vortex of extreme theories, walking away from them when so many sacrifices have been made can be tough. While Riley says she doesn’t consider herself an anti-vaxxer and doesn’t want to be lumped in with such a stigmatised group, if she had her time again she wouldn’t vaccinate her children.
Joe Barker travelled from Melbourne. She loves her grandchildren but hasn’t seen them in two years: “I’ve lost my son and his children, and I was only able to FaceTime my granddaughter this Christmas.”
Her family didn’t want to engage in debate around the vaccine with her. Her daughter won’t allow her to visit while unvaccinated for her own protection, because there’s no one to look after her if she becomes sick. Barker doesn’t believe this is brought about by concern: “My daughter is using it as an excuse.”
The women dwell in unsubstantiated theories: falsified death certificates, collusion by the federal government and the United Nations for a new world order.
But when questioned, their theories don’t hold ground. At first, they tell me the Australian government is profiting off the vaccine. When I mention the huge economic downturn and contract procurement costs, they tell me politicians have family members in big pharma who are profiting.
When I ask how a COVID vaccine could produce a “new world order” they say the vaccine is a testing ground to see how compliant populations would be with mask mandates and check-ins before introducing digital social currencies and controls. I get the feeling a few of the women are afraid of change.
It’s a friendly community tinged with sadness: the women are bound by their losses, be it social, economic, or family. Most have withdrawn their superannuation funds to get by. All are distrustful of the government. I get the sense that if their concerns around vaccines were met with empathy or understanding to begin with, they might not have been sucked into fringe idealism.
But so drawn in are they now — one former primary school teacher from Sydney, Marina Krivoshev, watches a non-stop stream of a prominent anti-vaxxers as we speak — that they can’t turn back. Deeper and deeper the conspiracies will go, alienating them further from their old social circles but embedding them deeper into a new one.
“I get the sense that if their concerns around vaccines were met with empathy or understanding to begin with, they might not have been sucked into fringe idealism.” A kind notion but I’m not sure it holds up. I know and have met several anti-vaxxers – although they all claim to be hesitant rather than anti, but WOTEVA! I’m not sure empathy would help. If you shoe them empathy they start trying to explain why you are a sheeple. About 8% of the population are unvaxxed – and the internet has let them find each other to build their new community. They look like huge numbers, they are not. This is what dumbing down the electorate does.
Ironically its less than 2% unvaxed in Canberra – those that live here, not those from elsewhere.
I’m double vaxxed and anti-mandate. Suck on that.
at least your last sentence is correct even if the context is wrong.
go back to the official messaging at the start of 2020 and compare it to now. Especially the bit about children.
anyone for a Y2K martini? All the panic that At the stroke of midnight, the computers will lose their way and we will descend into chaos. Didn’t happen.
HIV didn’t wipe out the world either.
On another point of pseudo-conservative hysteria, Howard didn’t do the apology to the stolen generations as conservatives feared zillion dollar lawsuits once an acknowledgement of guilt had been made.
didn’t happen when Rudd apologised. Because the TOs just wanted recognition and an apology.
I hope you understand why I regard right wing politics, pseudo-conservativism, as inherently stupid and/or evil.
HIV did wipe out a lot of the world actually. But that was in poor countries, and I guess that doesn’t count for you.
As has been said time and time and time again to people like you, and I know there is no point saying it because you will keep on repeating the same ignorant mantra wherever you go because let’s face it, you couldn’t possibly be wrong right – as has been said, there reason that the Y2K meltdown didn’t happen is because a lot of good people worked very hard to make sure it didn’t. But I know you’ve been told that before. Doesn’t fit into your narrow, conspiracy ridden world view, therefore doesn’t get taken on board. What a yawn.
Superb propogandic ad hominem attack VJ. I am actually laughing out loud. There was not even one truth in that whole tirade. You’re the reason why I have no faith in the right wing.
I’m sorry? HIV was and is not a problem in Africa? Which world do you live in? I’ve been there and seen how devastating it is first hand. Maybe you should try it. Hardly ad hominem if what I say is true. You clearly don’t care about non white people.
As for the Y2K stuff, that’s well documented. I’m sure you did laugh out loud. You probably laugh at anything that doesn’t meet your sad little mindset. Interestingly at that time it was people like you doing the doomsday stuff. The rest of us read what was being said, looked at what techs said was being done, and were pretty sure it would be ok. There are heaps of articles out there from techs who worked on the issues. I won’t bother posting any. You clearly don’t read anything that doesn’t fit in with your narrow world view.
Not sure why you think I’m right wing. However any disdain I show for the left is because of people like you.
You must be from a different world because HIV is still widespread in not just Africa, but quite a few other developing countries including quite close to Australia. isn’t it ironic, HIV has higher rates wherever there are resources to be extracted.
Again with your unhinged assumptions, I don’t know anything about doomsday stuff, but you obviously do. Fortunately for me, I’m not partisan, so your assumption that I am a lefty is again way wide of the mark.
Your assertions about HIV in Africa are just a straw man. What was said was that it didn’t wipe out the world, which it didn’t. No claim was made about the HIV situation in Africa – you interposed the “no true scotsman” argument to dishonestly attack views you didn’t like. While your views on the Y2K are IMHO correct, distorting the truth in your HIV response does you no favours.
There are complete uninformed idiots across the entire spectrum of politics. Billy being an example.
I worked in IT for many years. The only reason Y2K wasn’t an unmitigated disaster was because of the $billions and person hours spent on updating systems and coding so it wouldn’t be. The reason many many more people haven’t died from covid is the extensive preventative social and health measures used over last two years and the introduction of vaccines. Without them you’d be looking at a much bigger death toll than the 1917-19 influenza outbreak. Not just from covid but from other potentially fatal diseases and accidents that couldn’t have been treated due to hospitals overcrowded with covid patients. This was a reality for a time in Italy, parts of the US and other countries for months at various stages of the pandemic.
Sadly, the ones I know, already believed a wide range of bizarre conspiracies before the pandemic even hit two years ago. This was just the icing on the cake. Nothing works, not empathy, not calm conversation, not even gentle ridicule at working around or through their strange belief systems. That’s why their families have cut them off.
Great comment. For many its not about vaccines (they all got vaccinated as kids for multiple things that would kill them) its about the conspiracy aspect. If it wasnt vaccines it would be something else unfortunately.
You are right, the people I know who are “ one of them” often consider themselves intelligent and aware.Many are just not quite educated enough and naturally fearful and contrarian. The politicians who prey on them are arseholes.
Agree, and think research has shown that those following conspiracies also have higher degrees of narcissistic personality disorder; at worse Dunning-Kruger effect.
This was a great piece Amber
Agree, actual and grounded reporting on the ground. Pity was not done when the story started during the Xmas NY break when media were very confused, trying to parse through responsibility for old Parliament fire, when there were no media ‘boots on the ground’.
I have had enough of these morons. My daughter works in Canberra and has been intimidated by then taking over the car park of her office. There are cases of them harassing people wearing masks and refusing to wear them when asked by shop staff. They deserve a law suit for targeting people who are not the ones who are the problem and in any case, there are very few mandates from the Federals, mostly states. Where you see the red ensign you can expect right wing tools.
Selfishness and mindful stupidity comes in many forms. 14th century flagellants during the Black Death come to mind.
Australia has some of the best vaccination rates in the world. Many of these ‘protesters’ are just lead swinging fringe dwellers.
Thanks Amber for going to the ACT and mixing with this group of social misfits and borderline mental health patients.
As I have said in the past, when you read or hear the comments made by these people you don’t know whether to pity them or to condemn them. They seem to be the Australian version of the American Trump type conspiracy theorists and other sorts of wackos. There is little doubt in my mind that many of them need mental health treatment – something I am sure that many have received in the past.
The fact that a number of these people were formerly teachers, nurses para-medics and from other professions, is a real concern.
On the one hand, the fact that there are so many people who hold these illogical and outrageous views is a very poor reflection on our education system and especially on our mental health system. On the other hand though, should we expect the situation to be any different when we live in a Thatcher and Reagan inspired neo-liberal economic free-for-all where it is ‘dog-eat-dog’ and ‘survival of the fittest’?
There is a local Koch Network linked think tank blog that weekly newsletter promotes a local ‘science presenter’ (what else?) to highlight ‘freedom protest’ events i.e. Canberra with coverage of Canada too, and encourage the spread of science misinformation.
The ‘freedom protests’ are quite consistent globally like ‘Tea Party’, Capitol Hill, Canada, Europe etc. i.e. Kochian ‘freedom & liberty’ against Covid/climate science, sensible regulation, govt. etc., mostly directed toward centrist government, then fringe media coverage covers, which becomes legacy media content for agitprop to a wider audience.
Much of the movement also shares Tanton Network nativism and slogans based on eugenics promoting ‘the great replacement’; deceased Tanton is Steve Bannon’s muse….
Thanks for that extra interesting information Drew.
Go onto youtube and look up sovereign citizen and first amendment auditor videos. I suggest not actually going to their channels and giving them hits because their videos make them a lot of money. Instead go to one of the channels that critiques them. Schrodinger’s Cat is a good channel, but he died a couple of weeks ago so you’ll be looking at old footage. Ragical is ok, if you can ignore his stupid animations. These movements are where a lot of this is coming from. And a lot of it is simply about making money.
Understand, but I see ‘Sovereign Citizens’ as yet another spin off, astroturfing along with other seemingly (and often unwittingly) linked fringe groups to both mask and promote radical right libertarian ideology or policies by opposing regulation, science etc.
DeSmog blog UK linked up anti-Vaxxers, well-being, alt right etc. originally in the US, as allegedly being quietly supported by KochNetwork linked think tanks which also crossover with TantonNetwork ‘architecture’ of influence on alt right (for latter Fox is central) see:
‘How the UK’s Climate Science Deniers Turned Their Attention to COVID-19. The coronavirus crisis quickly divided the population between those putting their trust in public health experts and others quick to question the science.‘ (10 August 2020).