It’s a well-established rule of thumb that the prime minister lies more when he’s under pressure. And once again that has been on display in an election campaign where some early success has given way to increasingly dire polling.
Last year Crikey published a dossier of Scott Morrison’s lies and falsehoods, shining a spotlight on the prime minister’s habit of misleading the Australian people. But with the election just days away, and the mistruths coming thick and fast, we’ve decided it’s time for an update. That’s why we’re publishing a new dossier of campaign lies and falsehoods, featuring 12 new examples from the past six weeks.
Only 12? We’ve lifted the bar a little for the campaign when the rhetoric gets heated, attacks fly both ways, and politicians adopt any position to get themselves out of a scrape. We’ve also kept the “lie” and “falsehood” categories to help identify the moments when the PM must know he is deliberately misleading voters.
For example, in Morrison’s attacks on Anthony Albanese’s support for a 5.1% increase in wages for low-income earners, he’s been all over the place. Until Albanese expressed his support, Morrison had been agreeing that workers should get higher wages, that higher wages were on the way, but that the government had no “magic wand” to make wages rise. (That in itself is a separate falsehood.)
But then Morrison warned that in government, Albanese’s support for wage rises would drive up inflation and interest rates. That is, Morrison has been completely inconsistent and has wholly misrepresented Albanese. But that’s regulation campaigning hyperbole, not lying or misleading.
But what is also different now is that some journalists have been increasingly willing to challenge Morrison’s lies. With previous lies and falsehoods, journalists would sometimes follow up a lie at a later date. But now some are pushing back hard against him during the same media conference.
For example, it was repeated questions from journalists on Morrison’s lie about adolescents being subjected to gender reassignment surgery that eventually forced him to admit that such surgery couldn’t happen. This represents a significant change from his time as prime minister from 2018-21, when journalists appeared to let him lie with impunity, before Crikey and journalists like Dennis Atkins began pointing out Morrison’s systematic use of lying.
Morrison also remains unique among politicians. Other prominent leaders such as Albanese, Josh Frydenberg and Barnaby Joyce have all engaged in typical election rhetoric, but none have strayed beyond that into deception territory.
The nearest was Frydenberg tweeting about the level of tax to GDP under Labor (he claimed it was 25.9% — it has never been 25.9% ever, and the highest it ever got to was 24.2% under John Howard; the highest it ever reached under Labor was 21.7% before the financial crisis). But Frydenberg seems to be claiming Labor would have raised taxes to 25.9% of GDP if it could have, so we’re calling that campaign rhetoric, not a lie.
And Albanese has certainly been guilty of misrepresenting, if not lying about, the benefits of his housing policy, which involves a Commonwealth copy of existing state schemes in which the government takes an equity stake in a home with low-income earners. Such a scheme, like Morrison’s superannuation-for-housing scheme, would simply push up demand for housing, albeit in a smaller and more targeted way (just 10,000 places a year) than allowing people to raid their super. Again, however, it’s campaign rhetoric, not lying.
Saturday could herald a whole new three-year term of Morrison lies, or bring to an end the career of a man who has made deceiving voters the very centre of his political persona.
He’s not leaving anything on the field in terms of deception — right to the very end.
During the interview with Leigh Sales on 7.30 earlier this week I recall Morrison saying I “balanced the budget”. I remember the Back in Black mugs bandied about by the LNP when an expected “balanced budget” was eagerly expected, but ultimately did not eventuate. Morrison’s disdain for the truth is deeply troubling and undermines our democracy in a similar way Trump did in America while in office.
The thing is Morrison is on display as PM. He cannot hide his true character.
Essentially he is a gaslighting, sociopathic, narcissistic liar
And they are some of his most appealing qualities.
I thought he was going to take off his bulldozer pants. Well he put them back on in Tasmania and nailed an eight year old to the ground in a game of football. All he could say was “hope that kids not in hospital”
What an absolute freak this idiot is!
My recollection was that the budget would be $500 million in the red. But the MSM let them get away with the “Black” idea.
Many of Frydenberg’s claims about how well Australia is doing against various economic indicators in comparison with the rest of the world are untrue. Are these not lies as well?
Were the lies told by this stinking, rorting say anything bunch told as part of a business prospectus they would possibly face a substantial jail sentence .
That is why as well as legislation for an ICAC with teeth, there needs to be such for Truth in Political Advertising as in South Australia back in the 1980s!
Under John Bannon’s Labor Government in 1985 Section 113 of the Electoral Act 1985 (South Australia) was put in place.
It provides for an offence if a person authorises, causes or permits the publication of an electoral advertisement if the advertisement contains a statement purporting to be a statement of fact that is inaccurate and misleading to a material extent.
In 1997, s 113 was amended to empower the Electoral Commissioner to act on complaints of misleading electoral advertisements, which can be submitted by anyone to the Electoral Commission of South Australia (‘ECSA’).
The long and short of it Hayward a lying rat should not be PM .Agre with you 100% and vote for your post
Like the “children overboard” Morrison’s lies will allow him to have another term at PM much to my disappointment.
The reason is that Australians do not care about being lied to – probably because they lie just like him and see that it is ok.
In my later years I have come to the conclusion that Australia is not the “great” country that I came to those many years ago starting with the sacking of Whitlam and the continued lies that are espoused in mainstream media.
My only hope is that future generations will understand what happened but I guess by then it will be too late as Australia will just become a junkyard full of holes in the ground where mines were used to pillage its sovereign wealth.
The problem is apparent lack of education, lack of critical thinking skills, lack of knowledge how elections in Australia work (is this not taught in school?). Add to it all that ‘aspirational’ crap politicians fill people’s heads with and you have a respite for disaster.
I feel exactly like you. When I arrived in this country,I fell in love with the country. I travelled many times around and into every corner of this big country, and I loved what I saw and experienced. But I don’t like watching the decline, what it has become and where it might be heading too. I feel like screaming and crying.
And let’s not forget the mediscare lie of labor that failed to get them across the line. Australians picked that lie from the get go
Mediscare wasn’t a lie. The LNP are still undermining Medicare by not increasing the amount GPs are reimbursed for consultations. From what I have read, this has led to GPs getting out of bulk billing and also a large drop in the number of medical trainees opting to become GPs = long-term problems for primary care as the LNP seeks to gradually privatise health care.
Mediscare was a lie, as you may remember the Medicare look a like emails Labor was sending to voters to have them think the Liberals were going to dismantle the Medicare system . This was a classic scam now used by bank scammers these days. By the way Labor first brought in a freeze on GP’s rebates from medicare in 2013.
Well, you know how it is – Liberal lie = Good, Labor lie = Bad.
Just like debt, unemployment rates, interest rates, etc, etc. If it belongs to the LNP, then by definition, it must be good, because they are the Born To Rule.
come on kmart you will have to do better than that. Anyway I’m off to Target now
At the end of the day, Morrison and his bunch of LNP cronies are just a reflection of ugly Australia. How did we sink so low? Australia just needs to look in the mirror.
A religious minority has finally taken over this country .They tried a massive branch stacking in Sth Austalia and were caught out and as a result, failed to get control of that state,they certainly have gotten control of the country and we are now governed by a religious group with beliefs that are dubious to say the least.
.May someone else’s god give us a miracle Saturday because this one is a dud
There are more examples than campaign rhetoric, Bernard. An example of an outright lie is Morrison changing what Albanese actually said about a Quad meeting after the election, which was if he was elected, he would go, to the claim that he presumed that he would wine and go Tokyo. That is a plain lie. Then we have Simon Birmingham follow up with the claim that the ALP will spend $440 billion more over four years. That is also clearly a lie.
Morrison just added another lie. “We are not going back to lockdowns. I have seen evidence that Albanese is thinking of going back”. This is another lie. No one in Australia thinks lockdowns will work with Omicron. Mr Albanese is no different from anyone else on this score and there is no indication that he is. This is not just rhetoric it is a lie.
It’s not up to the federal government anyway. That is a state call.
Morrison never allows fact and reality to interfere with his lies. And most of the electorate doesn’t pay enough attention or cares enough to realise what he’s doing.
And none of the media pick him up on his constant lies.
Part from Crikey and Independent Australia most media here in Australia ignore such
What should be happening is something akin to The Washington Post FactChecker as one example of such in the US.
His lies run out of his mouth like water from a hose