The Greens should be on a roll. Off the back of a historic election result that could cement the party’s lower house representation long term, and with the political agenda now dominated by the Greens’ bread-and-butter issues of climate, accountability and Indigenous affairs, the political tide has moved in the Greens’ direction even more dramatically than in the 2010 election.
Labor is also demonstrably captured by fossil fuel interests and committed to expanding Australia’s massive contribution to the climate emergency via the gas and coal industry, so the Greens — along with the teals — should be making a bid for mainstream status as the politicians representing the majority view of Australians that much more aggressive decarbonisation is required.
Instead the party has mired itself in a series of rolling issues that, while small in the scheme of things, portray leader Adam Bandt as weak and distracted. Now, the entire federal Greens Party is starting to look weak and hypocritical.
Allegations of offensive and bullying behaviour against Victorian Senator and DjabWurrung Gunnai Gunditjmara woman Lidia Thorpe — first aired more than a year ago by First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria chair and Bangerang/Wiradjuri woman Aunty Geraldine Atkinson — have now been backed by Thorpe’s former chief of staff, who apologised to those on the receiving end of Thorpe’s alleged behaviour.
Nine newspapers’ Lisa Visentin, who revealed the apology by David Mejia-Canales, further revealed today that Atkinson had never received a response from Bandt or the Greens after she wrote to Bandt about the incident.
While not on the same level as Thorpe’s disgusting abuse of Liberal Senator Hollie Hughes late last year — Thorpe allegedly yelled “at least I kept my legs shut” at Hughes, who has a son with autism — the incident was serious enough that Atkinson sought medical assistance at the time. Thorpe later apologised and “unreservedly” took back her comments.
The Greens’ response, however, is that there is nothing to see here — it was merely a “robust” discussion, is the official line. No apology necessary, apparently. Move along.
If this had been a white Liberal senator yelling abuse at a stakeholder, especially an Indigenous elder, talk of “robust discussions” wouldn’t have got far with the Greens, who would have labelled it evidence of bullying and racism.
Plainly even some Greens are unhappy with this approach, given the leaking of internal documents today.
The Greens, after all, are strong supporters of better workplace standards. “Everyone has the right to work in a safe workplace free of occupational hazards, including bullying, discrimination and harassment,” reads the Greens’ workplace relations policy. The Greens have been vocal in their calls for a better standard of conduct in Parliament — not merely in Canberra, but in other parliaments. The Greens have also been stalwart long-term supporters of greater transparency in government.
Their response to the Atkinson allegations is anything but transparent and supportive of better standards of workplace conduct. In fact, they look a lot like a mainstream political party hoping that by stonewalling, the media will lose interest in a scandal. Supporters are entitled to expect better from the Greens, who’ve long insisted they’re a cut above the poor standards of the major parties.
Lidia Thorpe is a loudmouth and loose cannon who should be kept out of the limelight by the Greens and not pre-selected for the next election. She is notorious for manufacturing grievances for her own agenda and attacking other people in politics.
I agree. Not to mention Ms Thorpe dipping the Australian flag in fake blood, cutting it up and then setting fire to it! What the hell is she doing in the ‘AUSTRALIAN’ parliament????
I will never vote for the voice for many reasons, but indigenous people like her is one of them. She is dangerous to this nation!!
She reminds me of Mark Latham: I wanted to vote Labor in that election but I did not want to elect a thug; I want to vote Green but I do not want to elect a thug. How do these people get preselection?
Well said (again) Bernard. I like the way that you call out hypocrisy regardless of the person guilty of displaying it. I also thought that the cartoon at the head of this article was terrific!! I had a good laugh.
For me, the Greens are something of a conundrum or a quandary (or should I make that an ‘enigma’?). I want to support them but it is things like this that prevent me from doing so.
cool – so by the same standards, you’re also not voting for LNP or Labor – so I’m hoping you have a good independent to vote for
You bet I am NOT voting for the LNP or its sister organization the ALP (Alternative Liberal Party). I voted for Zoe Daniel at the recent Federal Election and I will be voting for the Sustainable Australia candidate in the forthcoming State Election. I hope that that satisfies your requirements.
I envy you having Zoe Daniels as an MP.
Yes, Rhonda, I have lived in this electorate for about 70 of my 74 years. For the first time in my life, I feel that I have a local member who represents me. I am still getting used to calling her ‘my member’; it is a strange feeling. It is certainly the first time that I have voted for the sitting member here in Balaclava/Goldstein.
I am sure that there will be instances where I will disagree with her but nevertheless, it is such a ‘breath of fresh air’ to have Zoe as our member instead of the foul stench of a sitting Liberal.
I hear you Robert! After many years of Ben Moreton as my local member (yech) I now have Sam Lim. Not quite in Zoe’s class but it is such a relief.
Thorpe is sqandering any chance to help her people. Mind you she’s not the only one brimming with self interest
Not just “her people”, she’s squandering her, and her party’s, chance to help anyone else and the environmental causes that are supposed to be dear to the Greens. It is inexplicable why she is not only tolerated but encouraged and promoted by her party.
Jacinta Price
Bandt is a weak Leader and Thorpe is simply childish (as demonstrated by her response to the arson attempt at Old Parliament House earlier this year).
The Greens seem to have fallen for the trap of collectivism, whereby it is anathema to even be seen to criticise the opinions or actions of another member of the collective. They seem determined to undermine the indigenous Voice, because it comes before their preferred approach to reconciliation with indigenous Australians (that it is, a highly symbolic treaty).
I’ve been a Greens supporter since the demise of the Australian Democrats. However, with the re-emergence of the latter, I can no longer help a party which allows Lydia Thorpe to carry on as she does.
Toxic Thorpe is a sociopath and should be disendorsed.