The most shocking reaction to the ABC’s exposure of the sickening cruelty at the heart of the greyhound racing industry has come from senior Nationals MP Barnaby Joyce, who instead of criticising those who have engaged in illegal practices such as live baiting, attacked those who exposed it.
One of Joyce’s Coalition colleagues, former vet Chris Back, has put forward legislation proposing that people causing “economic damage” by trespassing to obtain evidence of illegal or unethical practices be jailed for up to 20 years. Another of Joyce’s colleagues, his parliamentary secretary Richard Colbeck, wants to amend competition laws to ban people from calling for boycotts of companies.
Joyce and his colleagues, it seems, are eager to protect the rights of people who torture animals, while believing those who expose them to scrutiny should be locked up and fined.
“Sports” that exploit animals are reprehensible enough. But greyhound racing is a bizarre kind of mediaeval legacy, one that has long been associated with well-evidenced claims of the systematic abuse of both the dogs themselves and other animals, including the wholesale slaughter of dogs deemed not good enough to race.
There are, of course, many participants in the industry who treat their animals well and avoid unethical and illegal practices such as live baiting and doping. But the cruelty of greyhound racing will be systemic as long people can make money from it. It should be banned.
We could also ban horse racing for similar reasons – except that there is too much money involved.
Cousin Jethro is consistent – he didn’t like the abuses of the live export trade, including the failure of self-regulation, exposed either. That got in the way of profits too.
Anyone reasonable person who watched 4 corners would have been as disgusted as I was at what was going on. What has been rumoured for years has been proven correct – at least across significant parts of the industry. I would fully support the close-down of this industry until they can prove that cruelty has been eliminated (a difficult task I’m sure). As for horses (Frank @ post 1), I don’t think a straw-man argument is going to help. One of my kids works as a trainer & I can assure you that the horses are treated better than a significant part of the human population who most of us choose to ignore. I’m sure instances can be provided to the contrary but professional racing horses are far too valuable to mistreat. Even old horses look forward to a retirement at rest or on stud duties (in my experience). Certainly can’t say the same about any other working animal.
Joyce made a woeful shadow Minister for Finance before being dumped back in 2010, he’s now exceeded that low as Minister for Sport.
Tasmania had a go at putting up legislation that could get used for SLAPP – ultimately this got defeated because the other states wouldn’t buy in. It looks like it got shifted to the federal arena. We need to oppose this law *not* because of its being used here, but because it’s a bad law in general.