Christopher Pyne’s apology won’t be enough. It won’t be enough because he never actually did anything wrong. All he did was provide a pretext — and a trivial one at that — for Malcolm Turnbull’s enemies within the Liberal Party and at News Corp (hilariously, the crowd who normally bleat about free speech) to go feral. If it wasn’t Pyne’s remarks, they would have manufactured another excuse. After all, there was an important legislative victory to taint.
We’ve seen all this before. Julia Gillard could rarely enjoy any win without a Kevin Rudd supporter, or Rudd himself, running up to the Press Gallery to stir things up. Any impression of achievement or outcomes cannot be allowed to settle, lest the incumbent generate some momentum — the sense of chaos and discord must be permanent.
Pyne abasing himself won’t placate them. Granting concessions of any kind — whether by promoting conservatives, or demoting Pyne, or even by asking Tony Abbott to return to Cabinet — won’t work, because the goal is the destruction of Turnbull. The right has done well by Turnbull — conservatives Peter Dutton and Mathias Cormann are highly influential; young reactionaries like Michael Sukkar have been given a chance. But it availed Turnbull naught. He needs to fight back, not treat with his enemies. They are fewer than they appear: Abbott and his old white male spear carriers Eric Abetz and Kevin Andrews — the-day-before-yesterday’s men — the shrill chorus of rightwingers at The Australian and the News Corp tabloids, and shock jocks like Ray Hadley screeching to the converted.
The key to fighting Abbott is policy. That’s his weak spot. He can’t count and he can’t reason; all he can do is attack. Of course he rejects the idea of shutting down the school funding wars. War is the only thing Abbott understands. As his prime ministership showed, he can only ever be a negative, destructive figure, incapable of building anything; when it came to positive policy, everything Abbott touched turned to shit (remember how he was going to be “the infrastructure Prime Minister” and infrastructure spending fell of a cliff under him?).
The contradictions of his policy ideas, and his DLP-derived belief that government intervention is the answer to everything (government handouts for climate action, governments building coal-fired power stations, governments telling people who they’re allowed to marry, governments being able to override the senate), need exposing. The performance of his government, which dramatically increased spending, taxation and the deficit — a rare feat — should be discussed. His glib ability to furiously demand things he either failed to do or actively opposed when in government should be brought to an end.
Nor should Turnbull have to do this himself. Treasurer Scott Morrison should be going after Abbott (if he wants some tips, he can give Wayne Swan a call). If the objection is that this will keep the focus on the government’s divisions, well, the focus is going to keep swinging back to them whether they like it or not. Continuing to pretend that all is well, that the Liberal Party is a broad church etc etc, simply wastes time that could be put to use highlighting Tony Abbott’s hypocrisy and policy vapidity. He won’t stop. Target his weak spot and keep hammering until he’s made to.
I don’t think that is going to happen. This movie is going to take very predictable story lines to the very end.
Very prescient I suspect. Your interpretation of the plot however , is probably different to many voters.
I could not agree more.
I’d go further – the very reason the so-called ‘moderates’ in either the Liberal Party or the National Party (I know, I know… but still) are in the position they are now is because they sat back in their club room chesterfields and arrogantly supposed that the influx of reactionaries during Howard’s time could be countered by the social and business ties of the Hooray Henrys, Old Boys and Boardroom Boys.
They made very lazy and grave error of judgement then, and the PM make a very grave error of judgement when he signed himself away for the ‘big chair’.
Whatever our political persuasions, this country is likely to be governed by the LNP for around half the foreseeable future.
If what is left of sane conservatives (I know, I know) don’t stand up and do serious battle with the reactionary cabal both inside and outside the Parliament now, right now – the consequences are likely to be dire, for everyone.
Seconded.
Thirded.
“Chesterfields “? Seriously? You don’t know many current Australian politicians obviously.
Derryn Hinch gave some advice, publicly, to Turnbull this week ie: when parliament resumes put same sex marriage on the agenda ASAP, ignore all braying from LNP colleagues & make it a conscience vote. The legislation will pass both houses – the voters know this & the majority want it.
This will effectively enrage & emasculate Abbott who currently believes Turnbull is gutless, insecure & lives in fear. Turnbull needs to stand up to the bully; same sex marriage legislation would demonstrate he has a backbone (even if he hasn’t, it would create the impression he has). Once passed, no politician would dare undo this legislation, Abbott & his hardliners will have been outmanoeuvred.
Turnbull has nothing to lose by taking such a tack – he has everything to lose if he doesn’t.
Seconded.
Too right Zut Alors. Problem is, Malcontent hasn’t shown the fortitude to tell Abbott and his yesterday’s men to get lost. That bunch of Luddites are totally self-deluded.
If the PM brings a conscience vote , he will be tossed out on his ear. The Plebiscite is Gov policy. People of all opinions on the matter voted for the plebiscite. People of all opinions demand their right to have their say via the plebiscite. What is so hard to understand about this?
These ‘people’, for whom you presume to speak, want a say on which of their compatriots should have fewer rights?
They don’t sound very nice, or bright, so I am happy that they are side lined – it’s just a pity that such types cannot keep their bigotry to themselves, consenting adults and all that.
For the record, I oppose idea of gay marriage for the same reason that I oppose the idea of female priests – think about it, what do they have in common?
Brilliant BK. Bang on it. Politics is pretty simple at times like this, all you (vast majority of) moderate, centrist, rational, would-be policy/pragmatic Lib-Nats: either govern, or get out. Fight, or fuck off. Liberally shit, or get off the liberal pot.
Crackerjack stuff BK.
The sooner this stain on Australia is scrubbed from the porcelain bowl that is Canberra, the better.
Dare I say Turnbull should hit back hard right now at the point where the weirdo will be circling the wagons for his mentor, Pell? Anyone who wouldn’t hit now isn’t ruthless enough for politics.
I’ve been thinking exactly the same thing about Abbott and his confessor-in-chief myself. As Tim Minchin would have it: “Come back Cardinal Pell”.