They say you never forget your first time.
Mine was during my Queensland high school years way back in the 1980s, when the local newspaper published a letter in which I pointed out that the author of a previous letter denouncing the commercialisation of Christmas by our culture’s “traditional enemies” was a well-known supporter of the anti-Semitic pseudo-historian David Irving. The following week, some anonymous person posted me a newsletter from the notorious far-right Australian League of Rights.
I try to remind myself of the sense of shock at receiving that hate-filled envelope when listening to shaken young Muslim women describe their own first experience of being targeted by racists for daring to participate in public discourse. This type of harassment has become so normalised that the ugly scenes of Sam Dastyari surrounded by mocking thugs from the United Patriots Front (or as they pedantically corrected Dastyari when he referred to them by that name, “Patriot Blue”) would hardly come as a surprise, had the so-called patriots not been so proud of their work that they filmed it and posted it on social media. Muslims from the beer-drinking Dastyari to the headscarf-wearing Yassmin Abdel-Magied have been forced to run the same gauntlet of harassment and abuse. My own book launch last year was interrupted by the ranting racist at the back of the room who (in Helen Razer’s words) “began with ‘How can Mrs Hussein possibly justify …’ and ended, about twenty years later, with … ‘the religion of Satan!!!'”
Dastyari responded to the bullies in the pub by calling them racist rednecks. I told the Ranting Racist in Readings that I am not Mrs Hussein to anyone, that my friends call me Shakira but since he clearly didn’t want to be my friend, he could call me Dr Hussein. But coming up with the perfect comeback line on the spot is less important than the responses that come after the event.
As you would hope and expect, both Malcolm Turnbull and Bill Shorten have denounced the attempt to bully Dastyari. As you would also expect, Pauline Hanson declined to follow their lead, accurately describing Dastyari as “a smartarse” and less-accurately implying that the whole incident was probably just a publicity stunt by Dastyari himself. So far, so completely to script.
It’s very easy for anyone-who-isn’t-Pauline-Hanson to denounce bullies like Patriot Blue. It is more complicated to work out how to respond to their stunts without amplifying their voices. One of the most commonplace responses is to explain exactly how the racists are mistaken — as though, in Ghassan Hage’s words “the racists’ greatest sin is that they are bad thinkers” — thinking that anti-racists then scramble to correct. As if in anticipation of the Patriots’ demand to know “what race is Islam?”, on Tuesday New Matilda published an article by Michael Brull which was described as “destroying” the “but Islam’s not a race” comeback. Victorian MP Tim Watts’ straight-into-the-camera “What race is dickhead?” response to Dastyari’s bullies was far more to the point than was Brull’s point-by-point unpicking.
I’ve done more than my share of fact-checking racism myself, on everything from female genital mutilation to headscarves to halal-certified food to yes, that familiar favourite, “Islam is not a race”. Michael Brull has not “destroyed” that particular axiom any more than I did. It is the cockroach of political memes, destined to survive the apocalypse.
Let’s not respond to stunts from the so-called patriots by fact-checking their racism, then. And more importantly, let’s not allow them to distract us from the much more powerful racist bullies who are responsible for the closure of remote Aboriginal communities and the internment of asylum-seekers in offshore detention centres in violation of international law although not (it is becoming increasingly clear) in violation of the legendary and much-lauded “Australian values”. “Ordinary Australians” might be shaken by the patriots’ ugly stunts, but they also use it to console themselves that this is what real racism looks like. It doesn’t look like their local MP (although it may look a bit like their One Nation Senator), it doesn’t look like the mainstream media that they consume every day and above all, it doesn’t look like them.
Except it does.
Wow. Shakira/Dr Hussein as usual nails it. I just hope those wielding cultural and political power will heed her words.
Thanks, Shakira. How difficult it must be to live well when so many days bring another blow on the same deep bruises. I live in the hope that the fear mongers and their ugly talk will fade from the daily news before they trigger something really fearsome.
Respect, in solidarity and hope.
I’m not one of Sam’s greatest followers (understatement) but he didn’t deserve that. And I’d defend him against the yobbos.
I believe that Pauline Hanson’s latest incarnation as an Islamophobe is the product of the dog-whistle rhetoric of the War on Terror. Howard stopped the Tampa before anyone died at sea, but also before 9/11, and then used that attack to demonise refugees as somehow associated with the terrorists. He, Bush-Cheney, and Blair escalated their rhetoric before and after Iraq to distract from their obvious lies, and while there was some resistance from Labor, many in Labor bought into it (the neocons–Beazley, Rudd, Danby et al.). All Pauline and the so-called Patriots do is regurgitate the impressions that the governments of Aus, USA and UK were happy for them to absorb. (This is borne out by the fact that quite a few Patriots are ex-military.) I think Trump’s attitude to Muslims is similarly acquired. So where I believe Dastyari erred in his blame is to pin Trump and Hanson as unleashing this behaviour, when in truth they like the Patriots are products of the Establishment’s cynical disinformation to justify unjustifiable policies. And while Australian Labor isn’t entirely to blame for Iraq (UK Labour and US Democrats are though), they are equally culpable for the appalling mistreatment of refugees, which they lie is to stop deaths at sea, all the while knowing that it is only popular because most Australian have been conditioned to fear/hate Muslims. Dr Hussein’s final paragraph is spot-on.
Excellent point, Labor bear immense responsibility for the current political climate as well, and are certainly culpable when it comes to where we are at in this county with our abhorrent policies regarding asylum seekers. That said, I wouldn’t extend too much blame towards Dastyari personally, as you can bet your bottom dollar he wouldn’t be supporting these policies in the party room.
To a certain extent you’re right in that there’s no arguing with ideologues, but the lesson I think would have been valuable to extract from your encounter with the “religion of Satan” bedlamite is that it was time to learn how to respond to such statements with resolute and effectual counter-arguments in future.
Having written a book on the plight of Muslim women, it stands to reason you’ll be able to decisively refute poorly formulated anti-Islamic rants. It’s not enough to assume that other commentators or the media will have your back post factum.
To quote John Stuart Mill:
“He who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that. His reasons may be good, and no one may have been able to refute them. But if he is equally unable to refute the reasons on the opposite side, if he does not so much as know what they are, he has no ground for preferring either opinion… Nor is it enough that he should hear the opinions of adversaries from his own teachers, presented as they state them, and accompanied by what they offer as refutations. He must be able to hear them from persons who actually believe them…he must know them in their most plausible and persuasive form.”
JQ,
Excellent reply
& extremely well-made points.!
I will take them away with me for use in the future.!!!