Dan Andrews’ police state, Julian Assange waits on a phone call, and brands love saying they hate racism (while doing racist things). Catch up with all the latest tips and murmurs from the Crikey bunker.
Lora Norder
This morning Victorian Premier Dan Andrews warned people planning to protest against police treatment of Indigenous Australians this weekend: “If it is not peaceful, it is not a protest.”
He added: “Victoria Police will not tolerate violence.”
But what could Indigenous people in the “most progressive state in Australia” have to get angry about? It’s nothing like America — apart from the rate of Indigenous incarceration which has steadily increased under Andrews’ watch, the insidious militarisation of Victorian police, the expansion of policing roles and last year’s $1.8 billion prison expansion fund?
While the grotesque response of, say, New South Wales minister for police and human scandal factory David Elliott to heavy-handed policing of an Indigenous teenager would surprise no one, it’s worth interrogating Andrews, who frequently governs contrary to his more “progressive” rhetoric.
This is now, that was also now
As a subplot to the ruptures across the United States yesterday, Channel Seven journalist Amelia Brace and camera operator Tim Myers were among the many journalists attacked by riot police trying to clear the way for a presidential photo op. Prime Minister Scott Morrison — quite rightly — got swiftly on the blower to sort it out.
“The Prime Minister has informed us he’s been in touch with our embassy in Washington to have the matter urgently investigated,” the network’s news and public affairs boss Craig McPherson told The Australian.
Meanwhile, in the UK, Julian Assange’s hearing continues — although the man himself is too unwell to front court. We’re sure the Walkley-winning publisher facing 170 years in prison if extradited to the US would have loved a similar call at literally any point in the past decade.
The commissioner and Lawyer X
Shane Patton is the new chief commissioner of Victoria Police. According to journalist John Silvester’s extremely positive column reacting to the news (“He did what was right and would stare down those who wanted to lead him down dark paths”): “The search for [Graham] Ashton’s replacement was worldwide, [but] the smart money from the start was on a local and the smartest was on Patton.”
The problem with looking local is that practically anyone who has held any position of power in Victoria Police in the past few decades is going to find it hard to avoid at least proximity to a scandal.
While Patton had the gumption to go against his former boss during the Nicola Gobbo/Lawyer X royal commission, he was also part of efforts to keep the issue under wraps. In 2016 he went so far as to tell the director of public prosecutions — who had tried to tell several of Gobbo’s clients their convictions may have been unsafe — that court suppression orders prohibited him even using the term “Lawyer X”.
Corporate compassion
We could fill a daily column with examples of huge brands hopping on the social justice bandwagon, suddenly attaching their voice to a hashtag that just happens to be attracting the most eyeballs on Twitter and Instagram — and in some ways perhaps we should be glad that corporations see that as the way to greater profits.
But one or two really do stand out.
For example, L’Oreal’s sudden commitment to dismantling state-led oppression and racism:
The news that “speaking out is worth it” must come as a shock to Munroe Bergdorf. In August 2017 she became the first openly transgender model to front a L’Oréal UK campaign.
Following a now-infamous neo-Nazi rally in Charlottesville, Bergdorf posted (and later deleted) her exhaustion at “the racial violence of white people”. For her troubles she was ditched by the brand by September 1.
Then there’s Arsenal whose commitment to racial equality doesn’t seem to extend to China’s oppressed Uyghur minority, or at least those who speak out for them.
Finally, we’ll present this without comment:
Have you got a tip for Crikey? Let us know.
“Redskins”. Do minority Indigenous sensitivities matter – anywhere?
The idea of offering asylum to Hong Kong citizens seems good for Australia. Perhaps Australia should likewise be preparing to also admit USA refugees in the event of Trump being re-elected in the November elections.
In a bold bid to raise the hypocrisy stakes the San Francisco 49ers also had a black screen on Tuesday. Of course that was the team that fired Colin Kaepernick for taking a knee in peaceful support of black lives matter.
RE: Shane Patton as new Chief of Police in Victoria, championed by John Silvester, is so incredibly disappointing.
In my view, a person who stood up to corruption (let us call it what it was) and was pushed out for their honourable stand should have been appointed. They should have appointed Sir Ken Jones.
This is the only kind of person acceptable. Someone who was prepared to stand up for what was right regardless of the consequences to themselves. Someone who could see: lawyer x is not the problem, it is the symptom of a bigger problem: That Vic Pol is awash with police who just want a promotion and go for gold and personal glory rather than looking at systemic policing. The kind who will spend tens of millions and break any rule necessary to find the killer of one criminal at an Auskick clinic – looks great on their resume – than fix a broken system that allows and accepts one dead woman every week from family violence.
Don’t let the Royal Commission into Family Violence fool you. Nothing much has changed and police still hate dealing with ‘domestics’, even though 40% of crime is just that. Police don’t join the force to deal with it, they join to catch the current Carl Williams or Mick Gatto.
But the majority of policing is domestics and our system is not set up to protect the hundreds of women being beaten every day and the one a week being killed through family violence.
Is Shane Patton the kind of person who would fall on his sword before accepting the shameful breaches of the Rule of Law we have been living with in Victoria? Or is he the kind to fall in behind his dirty leaders, regard it as shady but necessary, accept it and hide it?
We should certainly not be accepting a Victorian who still has his job. Especially one from St Kilda (the station with the worst reputation – the one where there were drugs and guns hidden in the ceiling).
What a shame. No fresh cleanup. Nothing of the sort. Victoria is once again, giving the absolute top position to a person who just played the game and tried to cover up rather than uncover an absolute scandal. Not good. Same old same old.
Furthermore, what a shame it is being reported by Silvester as some kind of win! Maybe the decades of reporting and connections with police have sullied his clarity.
This kind of appointment is the kind done by governments to appease, not to affect real change. We need a complete wash. A dismantling and a remake.
The government should only be considering people who lost their job due to their honour and their integrity. Not ones who pulled the line. Anyone with even a whiff of lawyer X on them should be already gone. Not promoted.