Welcome, Oz. Welcome to the ugly reality of falsehoods in the 21st century.
I naively thought the digital revolution would mean truth would be defeating lies by now, but I’m afraid the truth is still lagging.
I’m the founding editor of PolitiFact, the largest fact-checking site in the United States. I came to Sydney in 2013 to start PolitiFact Australia because your wonderful country met my two criteria for expanding our fact-checking: the articles would be published in English, which enabled me to assure our quality journalism; you had great beer.
I quickly saw that your journalists wanted to follow our lead and catch politicians who exaggerate and say things that are not true. And, sure enough, PolitiFact Australia kicked off an energetic fact-checking movement in Oz that continues today.
That’s because there’s a need. Your politicians, like ours, are getting quite adept at saying things that are not true. I saw that start in the days of Julia Gillard and Tony Abbott, and I hear that your problems are worse today.
I feel your pain. The United States lived through four years of Donald Trump’s falsehoods and then, after he lost the election, we endured a crazy two months with so many bogus claims about the ballot counting that they collectively became known as “The Big Lie”.
The Trump presidency and the avalanche of falsehoods prompted a reckoning about our terminology. There’s been debate about whether fact-checkers and political reporters should use the term “lie” (which the dictionary defines as “to make an untrue statement with intent to deceive”) or just stick to calling statements false.
In the US, some fact-checkers and mainstream outlets occasionally used “lie” to describe Trump’s ridiculous claims. Glenn Kessler, The Washington Post fact-checker, used the word in 2018 when he became convinced that a plea deal with Trump confidant Michael Cohen proved Trump had lied about hush money to porn star Stormy Daniels and Playboy model Karen McDougal. The New York Times began using the word in some news and analysis stories in 2016.
PolitiFact doesn’t regularly use this word, but it does have the “lie of the year” award (an honour no one wants to receive) and a “pants on fire” rating (reserved for the most ridiculous falsehoods).
I used to be wishy-washy about calling something a lie. I was more concerned with the substance of debunking a falsehood than the noun we used to describe it. But after seeing how the false claims damage our discourse and erode democracy, not just in the US but around the world, I’m more willing to use the word.
In fact, I’m now writing a book. The topic: lying in politics.
Bill Adair is the founding editor of PolitiFact, and Knight Professor of the practice of journalism and public policy at Duke University, North Carolina.
There is nothing new here that as a Crikey subscriber I did not know. Hopefully being able to disseminate this to non subscribers may increase an awareness of his character. Unfortunately I believe there will be way to many who just don’t care.
Yes, Trump is a liar. But you act as if no US politician/president lied before.
Right now the US has a president who’s first presidential campaign back in the 1980s was killed by his lies about his academic achievements. And how many lies did he tell during last year’s campaign about healthcare, the bankruptcy laws, prison reform etc. watch again the recording of that debate where he lies with straight face to an incredulous Sanders. And no-one in the mainstream media (that used to regularly get hysterical about Trump’s behaviour) pulled him up on those lies.
And before him there was Clinton. And who could forget Nixon. And that’s not the full list…
So yes, Trump is an awful human being and he was a disaster as a president but let’s not pretend he was a new and unique phenomenon and everybody else is a saint.
also, lying in Australian politics didn’t start with Abbott.
The Hitch’s book about the Klintons, always a double act since her days on the House Judicial Committee investigating Watergate, was called “No-one Left to Lie To” – subtitled “the Values of the Worst Family“.
Pity we don’t have anyone here fit to write a similar tome on Scummo.
“also, lying in Australian politics didn’t start with Abbott.” One of the Crikey articles in this Lies & Falsehoods issue defines lies back to Fraser & Howard’s ‘Fistful of Dollars” campaign, a deception if not a lie, withdrawn after the election.
It defines a steady stream of lies & falsehoods, through Howard’s pathetic ‘Non core’ promises, Keatings L-A-W tax cuts withdrawal, Howard’s weapons of mass destruction excuse for war (“I wouldn’t change a thing” – Howard, when asked to reflect) children overboard etc. It’s a good read – I recommend it.
The concept of telling lies and falsehoods doesn’t exist when you have the God given power of auto-absolution. God’s gift to those who do his work.
I follow the principle that past behaviour is the best predictor of and individual’s future behaviour whether in appointing staff or in life more generally. Hence we should not be surprised by the mendacity and underhandedness of the current PM. After a chequered career in middle management, marked by early terminations by employers while have not forgotten nor forgiven him, Morrison became an electoral “representative” in controversial circumstances due to a campaign of lies, subsequently proven in a court of law. https://johnmenadue.com/alex-mitchell-does-this-ring-a-bell-justinian-21-march-2019/.
As he has given so shall he receive.
Politifact are no angels themselves:
https://anthonycolpo.com/politifact-quietly-retracts-fact-check-labeling-covid-19-lab-origin-theory-as-debunked-conspiracy/
Anthony seems like a loon.