Although Anthony Albanese’s early stumble on Monday heavily influenced media coverage, the Coalition hasn’t had it all its own way, according to the latest campaign insights data from Isentia.
Unsurprisingly, Scott Morrison’s actual calling of the election — with the media providing inordinate coverage of the ritual of the nation’s elected leader travelling to the Queen’s representative to seek permission to hold an election — dominated political coverage. Albanese’s stumbles on the unemployment rate and interest rates were the third-biggest issue in terms of volume of media coverage, after cost of living and inflation.
Morrison’s wrestle with the NSW branch of his own party and the various legal actions associated with it was fourth. Thereafter several issues that all favour Labor: aged care, childcare, climate change and the Morrison government’s reported shocking half-million-dollar payout to Alan Tudge’s former staffer Rachelle Miller, despite insisting Tudge did nothing wrong and will return to cabinet.
Isentia also noted that although by no means dominant, Morrison’s 1.3 million jobs pledge received a high volume of uncritical coverage — despite being easily demolished by genuinely independent journalists.
Again unsurprisingly, Morrison and Albanese dominate media coverage, though the prime minister had more than twice the volume of mentions (positive and negative) as the opposition leader, especially online. Everyone else was a footnote — but along the names earning some mentions were Clive Palmer, Tudge, Andrew Constance and Barnaby Joyce. Labor’s Treasury spokesman Jim Chalmers has had an unexpectedly obscure start to the campaign, coming in below housing and regions spokesman Jason Clare. Clare is part of the ALP campaign HQ team.
The PM’s decision to start his campaign in the Labor marginal of Gilmore helped elevate Constance to a dominant position in coverage in that seat over Labor’s Fiona Phillips. In Braddon in Tasmania, however, Labor’s challenger Chris Lynch substantially boosted his media coverage against the Liberals’ Gavin Pearce. In Bass, Labor’s Ross Hart dramatically picked up his media game against Bridget Archer on the back of Albanese’s visit — who three days later was getting her own boost from Morrison, though she found herself in the middle of intensive questioning about Morrison’s broken promise of a federal ICAC.
In Eden-Monaro, Labor’s Kristy McBain blitzed her opponent in coverage, making grant announcements in the coastal town of Narooma. For North Sydney, mentions of Trent Zimmerman still dominate, although positive mentions of independent opponent Kylea Tink lifted.
In terms of the emotional pulse of social media, sadness and disgust were both higher than long-term averages, particularly sadness, in part a response to Labor’s refusal to consider an increase in JobSeeker.
Isentia also has a fascinating metric on the proportion of time the parties devote to speaking about their own policies versus attacking their opponents. On that score, Albanese and Chalmers have so far been more positive, talking about their policies 57% of the time, compared with 46% for Morrison and Josh Frydenberg.
There are also some highly revealing metrics about what the different media organisations cover in terms of topic selection. The ABC dominated coverage of major issues, with underemployment, the Rachelle Miller payout, and the NSW Liberal court action receiving more extensive treatment than in other outlets, while issues like cost of living and petrol prices and the PM’s visit to Gilmore received proportionately less coverage than elsewhere.
In contrast, in News Corp’s coverage climate change was overrepresented compared with other outlets (as always, from a denialist perspective), as were petrol prices and Medicare, and it paid less attention to the NSW Liberal stoush or Morrison’s jobs pledge than other media groups.
Nine paid proportionately less attention to the Miller payout compared with others, but gave more attention to Morrison in Gilmore (and the poor history between Constance and Morrison over the Black Summer bushfires), but also focused on cost of living and petrol prices. In regional media, Prime Media — now owned by Seven — went hard on Albanese’s stumble, but gave little time to the Miller payout and almost completely ignored climate change. ACM outlets went hard on petrol prices, Medicare and climate change, but gave comparatively less attention to Albanese’s gaffe or aged care.
Isentia also analysed the nature of the coverage. It found that the ABC examined more nuanced and complex topics — such as underemployment this week — while commercial media were more likely to focus on cost of living or scandals and gaffes.
But where the ABC doesn’t stand out is in relation to climate change. It does not talk about climate change more than other media outlets. Indeed, it is News Corp that’s obsessed with talking about climate change, not the ABC, even as its commentators attack the ABC for paying too much attention to the issue.
And not much mention of Morrison’s disaster at the Rheem factory where after announcing the ‘creation’ of 1.3 million jobs it was revealed that that very same factory was moving some of its operations to Vietnam
Way overdue for this next generation (aka all those young) reporters on the campaign trail, to actually highlight POLICY SUBSTANCE, instead of continuous back-biting and gaffe reporting by leaders only, as has been done for eons!
A substantial percentage of the younger generation of voters are better educated, more socially aware and thus more able to see through the crap, so reporters NEED to show some cut-through also!
How about encouraging the (mostly) young reporters to get to recording and reporting statements by the VERY COMPETENT SHADOW MINISTERS who are a VITAL part of Labor’s TEAM ?
Eg Dr Jim Chalmers (Shadow Treasurer), Penny Wong, Tanya Plibersek, Richard Marles, Tony Burke, Mark Butler, Terri Butler, Chris Bowen, Katherine King, Mark Dreyfus, Katie Gallagher, Jason Clare, Amanda Rishworth – and more! Most of these MPs have already worked in ministries during the Labor governments from 2007 to 2013 period!
What surprises me that in response to Morrison’s attack that Labor is unproven and inexperienced Labor doesn’t constantly Hammer home the fact that many in the shadow cabinet have government experience. That includes Albanese.
Sometimes it really looks like Labor is just fine with being in opposition.
Morrison was an unknown quantity when he toppled Turnbull but of course that doesn’t rate a mention for Murdoch, Seven and Nine.
Hardly unknown.
His serial failures (and inexplicable pay-outs) pre politics, malignant mendacity and malleable morality had long ago been noted by those who matter, the owner$ aka big donor$.
So it seems that Murdoch, Nine and Seven are all backing the Coalition.
Is the public really so daft as to back a really bad leader and bad policy.
Is the sky blue? Is water wet?
You pose one of the great questions of our age.
Unsurprisingly, Scott Morrison’s actual calling of the election — with the media providing inordinate coverage of the ritual of the nation’s elected leader travelling to the Queen’s representative to seek permission to hold an election — dominated political coverage.
Gotta say I was very surprised at the extent and breathlessness of the coverage of the calling of the election. Plane leaves Sydney airport: plane arrives Canberra airport; middle-aged, balding, white guy walks from plane to waiting car; car leaves airport accompanied by two other vehicles; car drives along Canberra streets and then disappears behind gates as it approaches a building surrounded by gardens.
A debate between Morrison and Albanese is scheduled for next Wednesday?
I am 80. I haven’t got many years left. However the years may stretch to a seeming eternity if the next five weeks continues to be like the last five days.
or we are subjected to another three years of the most incompetent and corrupt government this country has seen
“or we are subjected to another three years of the most incompetent and corrupt government this country has seen”
Going by the MSM this week, all you need to know is is that the opposition leader couldn’t answer a gotcha question, so it’s all over, he’s finished and Morrison is the obvious choice! Election done! No need for in depth policy analysis, just a memory wipe of the last 3 (9) years. Go Scomo!
Even BK couldn’t leave it and move on. I expect this repeated monitoring of Albanese’s “gaffe “ from the MSM. And yet here we are on Crikey… words fail me.
I’ve just listened to a Guardian podcast on the ground in WA trying to figure out if the quite common expectation that the results of last WA state election somehow indicates what’s going to happen there on 21 May. Geez…. I feel like yelling ‘circle the wagons!’ It seems we’re surrounded by idiots – some guy saying that Labor is the extension of China; an old woman criticising Albo for criticising everything but not having solutions, because I guess Morrison solves problems (?); a youngish woman calling Morrison’s behaviour ‘faux pas’, because you know, he means well, just doesn’t know any better, it’s all harmless mistakes; someone else voting for the Coalition because ‘we have to get rid of McGowan’ (what the effing eff?!?) and the vaccine mandates – and people who clearly lack empathy and moral compass, exactly like the a Coalition, because how else could you even consider voting for this lot? Also, Ken Wyatt – so likeable and able to deliver for his constituents, and you know, he’ll pick up the phone if you call him, you won’t call the PM, right, he wouldn’t pick up, so you don’t care who’s PM but the local member is important. So you know, I guess, vote for Wyatt even if you don’t like Morrison, because, I don’t know, a vote for a nice Liberal local member won’t potentially lead to the unlikable and ‘a bit slow to act’, faux pas-prone Morrison keeping his job?
right now I really am just reduced to WTF? WTF? WTF?
btw – no, the state results most likely won’t translate into a federal landslide.
Having the “Gift of the gab” is the trademark of a conman, snake oil salesman, hot gospeller, rorter, and liar. Our PM is all of these .
You may trust a thief but you cannot trust a liar. Our PM is a liar and his promises are lies