Russia stands accused of committing war crimes. Fresh claims, including eyewitness accounts and pictures, have emerged about what appears to be random executions of civilians, including children, in the town of Bucha, near Kyiv. This morning, Human Rights Watch added its name to a growing chorus of voices — including the governments of Australia, the US, and Germany — condemning Russian President Vladimir Putin.
The Kremlin has consistently denied targeting civilians in attacks. But Crikey has spoken to numerous refugees who said they have either directly witnessed murders or have lost friends, families and neighbours in attacks against civilians. Here are three of their stories.
Attacked from behind
Diana Plyas is from the outskirts of Kyiv. Bright, articulate and wearing a scull-patterned scarf — we compliment each other on our excess of ear piercings — Diana is 16 years old and hopes to study clinical psychology. Her dream was to study abroad in Canada. Now, she just wants to return home.
Despite sitting in a heated tent, Diana’s jaw chatters as she speaks. She’s animated and jittery — next to her, her babushka (grandmother) Raisa turns a heat pack over and over in her hands and stares ahead.
Diana didn’t believe the war had really begun until her father — who has been in the military since the invasion of Crimea in 2014 — called her mother and told them to pack their bags and leave immediately.
Stuffing clothes into sports bags, she, her mother, grandmother and sister fled, running to the Makariv region, west of Kyiv. “It was an unwise decision because Makariv is completely destroyed,” she tells Crikey.
The family spent a week and a half living in bunkers, waiting for the shelling to stop. There was no electricity, no internet, no heating and no phone reception. With limited information, the family had to rely on word of mouth to know when it was safe to leave.
“There were Russian tanks just driving around the territory of our city town — so we couldn’t just go,” she says. On March 6, 10 days after the war had begun, they received word there would be green corridors to allow them to leave. But the journey would be treacherous, along a long road filled with Russians. She called her friends — and as they were speaking, bombing began on the street.
“Three or four houses from us were bombed by two rockets. So we had to hide. Everyone was even more scared than before because you don’t know if they started bombing our street,” she says.
Ultimately, they decided to risk it, creating a small convoy of cars with the entire street and starting to drive north-east, back towards Kyiv.
“When we drew to the exits of Moschun, Russians started shooting at our cars, so we had to drive like … [crazy].” They drove for three more days, stopping off wherever it was safe to do so before finally making their way to Siret in Romania. They plan to travel onwards to meet friends in Barcelona in Spain.
“At first I thought [the war] wouldn’t be so bad. But as the war went on, it turned out the other way completely … A lot of people were shot,” she said. Along the way, they received word that a family from their community — a woman, her husband and her son — had been executed in the street.
A 30-minute window of survival
Sofiya Zhukova has bright-blue eyes and seems older than her 17 years. She speaks to me from a scout hall in Mińsk Mazowiecki, a small city 40kms from Warsaw, Poland’s capital. The night before war erupted, she had been joking with her friends about the threat of Russia — it hadn’t felt real. But as her school evacuated and she fled home on an overcrowded minibus, stooped for four hours with her backpack between her feet, reality hit.
Sofiya lived with her parents, seven-year-old brother and 13-year-old sister in Borodyanka, a hundred kilometres north-west of Kyiv. She loves music and sings and plays the guitar. Her family spent a week in a bunker in Borodyanka before deciding to flee. They kept their bags packed and ready to go, speaking to family outside of the city for updates.
“We received a message from my uncle that we had to leave. So we just set off in the car and left,” Sofiya says. Thirty minutes after they had departed, she says they received messages from neighbours saying Borodyanka had been occupied by Russians — she calls them terrorists — who started shooting at those fleeing.
“They didn’t want people to leave with cars from the city and they just killed [them]. Whether it was children — it didn’t matter to them. They killed them,” she says.
“We don’t know if we would be alive if we would have left later.”
The journey to Poland took almost a month, with the family spending days in the car, sleeping in bunkers along the way. She worried about her mum, who Sofiya says didn’t sleep for the entire 21-day journey. Her siblings who were so nervous they became ill.
Sofiya assumed her whole family would be able to enter Poland together. Men between the age of 18 and 60 aren’t permitted to leave the country, though men with three or more children can stay with their families. But Sofia is just a few months over the age of 17 — the cut-off age — and her father was sent back deeper into Ukraine to support the war effort.
“Borodyanka now doesn’t exist. I don’t know what happened with my home,” she says. She’s heard Russians have become desperate and have started looting the largely empty city.
Isolated and under siege
Alona arrived at the border crossing in Siret, Romania, on Sunday morning with her two children. She’s waiting for a red minivan to depart, organised by the Romanian government, which will take them to the nearby Iași International Airport, where she’ll continue onwards to the Canary Islands in southern Spain. Snow falls around her as she speaks.
Alona worked at the Chernihiv power plant in northern Ukraine. Her tears give way to manic laughter as she tells her story, with her dog Molly strapped to her chest. When war broke out, the city lost power and water — with some residents resorting to drinking sewage water to survive.
“Planes were bombing everything, they were shooting at civilian houses. The library was destroyed, the cinema was destroyed,” she said.
With bridges bombed, escape was difficult, but her family managed to flee in a convoy with neighbours. As they arrived in Ternopil, a city between Kyiv and Lviv, she says Russians started shooting at them.
“My friend tried to cover his child’s body with his. A bomb went off nearby and they both died,” she says.
Alona and her children stayed in bunkers in Ternopil for two weeks. As the roads became more dangerous, with highways reduced to rubble, they continued their journey on foot searching for volunteers to help them evacuate.
“One-third of the city’s population is still there. I have friends with children, all their children, and they can’t leave because the bridges have been destroyed,” she says.
Despite the horrors they have witnessed, Diana, Sofiya and Alona are trying to survive by focusing on the future. Diana is looking forward to meeting her friends in Barcelona. Sofiya has a new guitar and sings the Ukrainian national anthem to crowds at fundraising events. Alona is taken back by the level of support she has received.
All think Putin should pay for his crimes.

Have we forgotten the atrocities in Vietnam? My Lai was only the best known. The carpet bombing of neutral Cambodia & Laos – still killing people? The use of Chemical weapons, white phosphorous & Agent orange?
Nobody has forgotten those atrocities, but atrocities committed by one Imperialist power does not justify atrocities by another imperialist nation. Need I remind you that Russia has form when it comes to atrocities of this kind….or have you forgotten the Katyn Massacre during WWII?
No I’ve not nor have hundreds of thousands the US population that protested in the streets to end that bloody war (they were not threatened with prison/gulags or poisoned for doing same nor were the media, in the US, threatened with 15yrs imprisonment for telling the “truth”)
The subject of this article is the atrocities in Ukraine, then maybe we could discuss the wars in Chechnya and Syria etc and the similar tactics used by a self appointed Czar psychopath who can’t be voted out of office until he kicks the bucket or is poisoned. The US currently operates a bit differently despite Donald Dumpsters best attempts at a coup…you want to choose your “poison” I’d still choose the US over Putin.
Of course we haven’t, but what has that to do with the atrocities perpetrated by Putin’s folly today?
Are they real, should be the question. The Nazi Azov batallion boasted of moving into previously held Russian territory, executing “collaborators’. There are your innocent civilians.
The US is squarely behind this, that is what.
If you can’t see that after all these years, you really are not paying very much attention..
Base ‘whataboutery’ to divert attention from current events for which you have no response? We should learn from own and others’ past mistakes, includes Putin too.
Relevance?
“Have we forgotten the atrocities in Vietnam?”
No. But why do you ask?
It does not serve the victims of a previous atrocious and unjust war to pretend that the victims of a present atrocious and unjust war do not exist.
Follow a link to “Standpoint Zero” which has an excellent forensic analysis of the killings in these towns. There is a very strong likelihood that the Azov battalion , which announced it was undertaking a cleansing operation to rid the area of “ saboteurs and collaborators” left behind after the Russian withdrawal, did exactly that. Executed those who they believe had collaborated or assisted the Russian occupiers. Check it out. Azov has form in these operations. Suspect anything that looks too pat in the middle of a nasty war. The psyops teams are at work here probably on both sides.
“Russian withdrawal”?
So Russian troops were actually in Ukraine?
Are you here to engage or just troll?
Not a Russian withdrawal as such .. a regrouping.
Prior to cleaning the Nasties out of Donbas, where they have them in a ‘cauldron’..
“Are you here to engage or just troll?”
Seriously, I had the same question.
I remember after the US wreaked death and destruction on Iraq in 2003, and all the pro-war commentators (especially in the Murdoch press) kept reminding readers for the next three years that the invasion was totally justified, and that the ongoing violence was just ‘Iraqis killing Iraqis’ and nothing to do with the US or its original decision to invade.
Back then, I could not see how anybody could possibly argue in good faith that the consequences of an invasion had absolutely nothing to do with the invasion itself.
The lesson then, as now, is that if you deliberately create a power-vacuum, then you are responsible for what then occurs in that power vacuum. And if you aren’t sure what will happen when you create the power vacuum, then don’t create it.
Good point. The problem is that the US have no concern for either the civilian population, or what “after” looks like, or reparation to destroyed lives and civilizations. Just move on to the next money-making fabricated war.
That’s how unchained capitalism rocks, Ozstralian. I’m just surprised that so many on this forum cannot recognise capitalism when cloaked in a Russian flag.
More than likely, I’d say, re Azov. One of Putin’s objectives was to remove the Nazi component, namely the Azov batallion. They parade around with Nazi regalia, and flags…if it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck…I suspect the civilian deaths are down to Azov, and the bombed out buildings are in Donbass, the result of Azov shelling. The US are quite comfortable enabling the lunatic right, using ex Gestapo personnel to staff the notorious SAVAK in Iran after the coup against Mossadeq, in the ’50’s. The US have no integrity, are prolific liars, and their attempting to stake-out the high moral ground is laughable.
The Benighted States imported as many of Nasties as quickly as possible, not just for their rocket technology, from Peenemünde -, most notably (and infamously) Werner “I Aim for the Stars but Sometimes Miss & Hit London” von Braun.
Wow Stephen…
That is a really important analysis..
Basically
Russians all out by March 30.
Azov, some of first units to enter Bucha on 1/2 April, ‘find bodies’.
What happened on March 31st??
These bodies MUST be forensically examined, ASAP.
Very very likely posed by Azov using already dead people.
Or, lacking sufficient numbers for the Dianified western meeja to really emote over, supplied them.
Trouble with your suggestion is, satellite photos show bodies in streets while Russians were still in occupation ie 3 weeks ago.
There’s another article posted on Crikey on which I’d appreciate your view: https://uat.crikey.com.au/2022/04/06/stalin-putin-tyrants-playbook-no-copycat/
Has anyone noticed that the number of comments on any given piece- #thee3, covid, climate, politics or 5 legged dogs etc – is usually in inverse proportion to their coherence, relevance and accutiy>
If posters here, presumably a small percentage of subscribers/readers (not necessarily the same), are any indication of the general level of community nous – let alone the soi-disant left (behind? out?) – then our next Head of State should be Hanrahan because he was such an optimist.
…”coherence, relevance and
accutiy>ACUITY”Firstly let me say that any War is an abomination, and should be avoided at all costs by measured and balanced Diplomacy.
Now, Its sad to say this, but I am very skeptical about any Media articles about the Ukraine war. I beleive a fairly large percentage of it to just be Western propaganda, especially from the USA that really should have no involvement in this War.
We don’t hear much coming out of Russia because they have been very much censored, and kicked off Socila Media Platforms, etc.
All we get each day is MSM articles, either from President Zelensky or his colleagues, (who are obviously vested interests that are going to paint pictures that they want the World to believe, so they answer all of his pleas for assistance), and from “Western” Opinion writers, including “Analysts”, telling us that Putin is the Devil incarnate, that he is menatlly ill, that he is despised in his own Country, that he doesn’t know what he’s doing, that he has no grounds for invading Ukraine, and that he is losing the War without any factual evidence to back up the assertions.
A bit of reading of History of actual events will show that Russia’s demands prior to this War were very different to what the Western narrative would have you believe. Things like the facts around the 8 year war that has been ongoing in the Donbas region, which is home to a majority of Russian separatists, and the further encroachment of NATO bases around Russia’s borders, including the possibility of Ukraine becoming part of NATO thus meaning even more NATO bases strategically situated around Russia’s borders.
Before the War started Putin was very clear with his main demands, and his frustration that Zelenskt wouldn’t even come to the negotiation table in good faith to work through these issues. He just flatly rejected them.
(1) That the Donbas region be declared Independent of Ukraine. This would put an end to the 8 year conflict
(2) That Ukraine should remain an Independent Country, and not join NATO.
Note: Putin has never said he wants Ukraine as part of Russia, or a revised USSR.
(3) That Crimea that had been formally annexed by Russia, be formally recognised as an Independent Country.
All 3 of these demands should have been negotiated in Good Faith, but instead we have a War.
So what do you think Putin has gained from all the death and destruction he has unleashed?
NATO and Nasties out of Ukraine.
No Western puppets on his borders.
Enough?
As I wrote earlier..
“At the failed Munich Peace talks in February 19th, 2022, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz ‘suggested’ that Zelensky refuse/reject the offer to join NATO, assuage Russian fears and as a precursor to REAL peace talks.
As we now know, (WSJ, April 2 2022) Zelensky (no doubt on instruction from this US puppet masters) refused.
WSJ again.. ‘in mid-January, the Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) of the United States, William Burns, secretly visited Kyiv, where he allegedly met with Zelensky and presented him with a plan to “attack” Russia.’
Unfortunately, Olaf Scholz and Manuel Macron both failed to publicly denounce Zelensky’s calculated and indescribably criminal refusal or call for a retraction of the invitation.”
Yes, the nasty puppets have been deterred.
Great work.
Finland and Poland are certainly much more in Russia’s orbit now, and I’m sure the people from Ukraine, once they realise how much worse an invasion by “the West” would have been, will be incredibly thankful to Mr Putin for services rendered.
What does “…a majority of Russian separatists…” mean? Is it separation by incursion? Stirring up by some foreign shit, or “earnest requests to leave” made by citizens of the Ukraine. They have been “dominated” by Russian coercion for centuries.
They (The Russians) want the lot. See what they did to the Ukraine in the 1930s.
I wouldn’t call photographs ‘painted pictures’ of Zelensky wanting the world to believe. Most of the armchair commentators seem to defocus on what is actually happening in real time and have taken virtual reality trip to detour around reality of the present situation which must be stopped.
Well described. Its a pity many of the pundits are not aware of those basic facts, for a bit of context, beyond “Putin =bad”, and “US/NATO/Zelensky=good”. The Americans are always lurking in the shadows, pulling the strings.
I’ve got to call bullshit on that one: see Putin’s 12 July 2021 essay “On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians”.
Putin knows exactly what he’s doing, his war aim is no longer the conquest of all Ukraine, it’s just the to secure the annexation of Crimea, with Donbas and the landbridge between the two areas in southeast Ukraine, which includes Mariupol, Melitopol and possibly Kherson.
Citizens of Mariupol have not been sent to Siberia as hostages, they’ve been permanently relocated so that Mariupol can be repopulated with “loyal” Russians.
Reportage is now, officially, at the “Belgian babies on Hun bayonets” stage – with rape & mutilation as added salacious detail.
All fake news innit?
It’s hard to get away with fakery when the entire country is covered by satellite photography, there are reporters on the ground and mobile phones are everywhere. Ukraine has been invaded and civilians including children are being raped, mutilated and murdered. Your snide comments aren’t clever, on the contrary they are insulting, stupid and heartless.
For a kultur now beyond Bradbury’s 451, when a picture is all and literacy lost, it is odd that the ability to ‘read’ an image seems nonexistent.
There has been little, if any, ‘satellite photography (MH17 anyone?), reporters are most emphatically NOT everywhere, just select locations and the pointing of ‘mobile phones’ is extremely selective, with careful framing and cropping.
I did not say reporters are everywhere, but they are on the ground in Ukraine. Also, you really need to expand your news sources further than Russian propaganda outlets. “Little if any satellite photography”?? Get into the real world. https://www.bbc.com/news/business-60762772
You should, for clarity, be more careful about your use of dependent sub-phrases – “there are reporters on the ground (and mobile phones are) everywhere”.
The article is a commercial puff piece, graced with a large pic of the pulchritudinous Dr. Rita Konaev, which really adds so much to the information rich verbiage.
Look more closely at those images and try to understand the get-outs in the legends beneath them.
“Maxar satellite images appear to show a long Russian convoy of military vehicles approaching Kyiv, Ukraine’s capital.”
“Satellites can be used to pick out images of individual vehicles and even road markings”
“pictures snapped by satellites in orbit have captured images which appear to show destroyed Russian helicopters, extensive damage to a shopping centre and residential districts in Mariupol, and a civilian tanker vessel on fire in the Black Sea.”
As I wrote above, the ability to read with comprehension has been overtaken by image dependence and that’s less a slippery slope than a pile of twisted corpses at the bottom of a precipice.
“Mr Glen is co-founder of Conflict News, an account on social media platform, Twitter…He bought and shared from the account satellite images from online service SkyWatch, which reportedly showed the massing of vehicles along the Russia-Ukraine border...Privately-owned companies (sic!) that launch and operate their own satellites – such as Planet and Maxar – have distributed many satellite images of the conflict zone.”
Might as well be from Bellingcat or the Syrian Humans Rights Watch – last heard reporting from its nerve centre HQ in…umm.. Coventry, UK
I don’t need correction from the person who didn’t even know there was satellite photography of the war in Ukraine. FYI there are around 50 working satellites above Ukraine, belonging to government agencies and to a variety of private companies including Maxar, MDA, Bayraktar, Capella and Planet. Instead of wasting your time parsing the BBC article, which however careful its phrasing is clearly more authoritative than the news service you use which failed to alert you to the satellite coverage, you should spend time digging yourself out of previous centuries and pay attention to this one.
Many of those “…50 satellites above the Ukraine…” – certainly the most advanced ones, belong the the NSA & “other 16 US intelligence agencies” (pardon the contradiction in terms) – would have detailed evidence & proof of “..children (are) being raped, mutilated and murdered…”.
Ask yourself why this is not made available (suitably declassified of course!), to the world.
Then, on the off-chance of any cerebral capacity remaining, ask yourself why similar data is not made available from those sooper-dooper sats. to the current show trial of the downing of MH17.
They would have measured – to the millimetre – the launch site & telementry as well as recorded every syllable spoken by whoever fired those BUK.
Could it be that hard evidence would not support the current propaganda?
I could hazard a guess but suggest that you give it a go.
A few hours ago you were totally unaware there was satellite photography in Ukraine and now you claim satellites record everything in the minutest detail including audio. Why don’t you ask yourself about that dizzying turnaround?
Just because you didn’t know about the satellite photography in Ukraine does not mean it has not been made available to the world. It is available, you could even buy it yourself, as the BBC article made clear.
In the MH17 trial, satellite evidence and the detection of the missile launch by the US government was made available to the prosecution. The US did not want the specifics of how its early warning system detected the missile launch disclosed in a public trial, for the perfectly sensible reason that if an enemy knew how it worked, they could work out how to bypass it. There was also some satellite photography provided by various sources to the trial, but as it was one-off unanticipated event, obviously there was nothing like the satellite coverage given to the ongoing situation in Ukraine.
I have to admire the chutzpah of someone who did not even know there was satellite coverage of the war in Ukraine, and who is gullible enough to believe the blatant lies of the Russian propaganda machine, to disparage the cerebral capacity of anyone else, but if it makes you feel better about yourself… however I can’t be bothered to engage further.
I gave you the benefit of the doubt in case you were simply deluded.
That is clearly not the case, you are merely mendacious.
https://www.reuters.com/world/pentagon-cant-independently-confirm-atrocities-ukraines-bucha-official-says-2022-04-04/?taid=624b43bd3225ef0001288ec4
There’s another article posted on Crikey on which I’d appreciate your view: https://uat.crikey.com.au/2022/04/06/stalin-putin-tyrants-playbook-no-copycat/
It’s my observation that several commentaries operating out of Yevgeny Prighozin’s Internet Research Agency in St Petersburg also use Greek nom-de-plumes.
Kυριλλικό?